I blew half a funded account’s daily allowance in one sideways morning because I trusted a moving average that was still telling me yesterday’s story. It was a Wednesday on EURUSD, price had been chopping sideways for hours, and my 50-period EMA kept flipping: above it I bought, below it I sold, and every flip cost me a stop. By lunch I was down 1,100 dollars on an account where my personal daily stop is 2,500 dollars, and I had not taken a single trade I actually believed in. The EMA was not wrong about the trend, because there was no trend. It was just too slow to admit it and too jumpy to ignore, and that combination is exactly what kills funded accounts: slow enough to enter late, twitchy enough to enter often.
In this article
- What the Hull Moving Average actually measures
- The formula, worked with real numbers
- The settings I use on a funded account
- How I read its signals: slope, not crossover
- The worked example: one week on EURUSD H1
- I tested it: twelve HMA trades against twelve EMA trades
- Where the Hull fails, and the mistakes that cost me
- How the Hull fits prop firm rules
- Frequently asked questions
That afternoon I replaced the EMA with the Hull Moving Average, and I have used it as my main trend line ever since. The Hull, or HMA, was designed by Alan Hull to solve the exact trade-off that was costing me money: a smooth average is usually a slow average, and a fast average is usually a noisy one. The HMA is built from weighted averages in a way that cancels most of the lag and then smooths the result, so it turns with price almost immediately while still drawing a clean line. On a funded account that matters more than it does anywhere else, because every false signal is not just a losing trade, it is a slice of a daily loss limit you cannot buy back.
What the Hull Moving Average actually measures
The HMA measures the same thing every moving average measures: where price has been lately, weighted toward the recent past. What makes it different is how aggressively it weights that recent past. A simple moving average treats a close from sixteen bars ago as equal to yesterday’s close, which is why it lags so badly after a reversal. An exponential average weights recent closes more, but it still drags a long tail of old prices behind it. The HMA uses weighted moving averages, where the most recent price in the window gets the biggest weight and the weight falls off linearly, and then it does something clever: it doubles the fast half-length average and subtracts the slow full-length average, which pushes the line forward in time and cancels most of the delay, and then it smooths that pushed-forward value with one short weighted average so the line does not jitter.
In practice, that means the HMA hugs price. When EURUSD turns, the HMA turns within a bar or two, where my old 50 EMA needed five or six bars to admit the turn had happened. When price chops sideways, the HMA flattens quickly instead of wobbling through price every few bars, which is the behaviour I actually trade: a flat HMA is my signal to stand aside, and a sloping HMA is my permission to look for entries. If you want the textbook derivation, the ProRealAlgos Hull Average documentation lays out the formula and the lag argument cleanly; what follows here is how I set it, read it, and size around it under funded-account rules.
| Average | How it weights price | Lag after a reversal | Behaviour in chop |
|---|---|---|---|
| Simple moving average (50) | Every close equal | Slow, five-plus bars | Smooth but late, traps you in old trends |
| Exponential moving average (50) | Recent closes weighted more | Medium, three to five bars | Whipsaws through price repeatedly |
| Hull moving average (16) | Weighted averages, lag cancelled | Fast, one to two bars | Flattens quickly, fewer false flips |
The formula, worked with real numbers
The formula looks intimidating until you work it once by hand, and I recommend working it once, because after that you stop treating the line as magic and start trusting what it is telling you. For a period N, the Hull is the weighted moving average of length square-root-of-N applied to an intermediate value, and that intermediate value is twice the half-length weighted average minus the full-length weighted average:
| Step | Formula | Worked numbers (EURUSD closes, period 16) |
|---|---|---|
| Half-length WMA | WMA of the last N/2 closes | WMA(8) = 1.0942 |
| Full-length WMA | WMA of the last N closes | WMA(16) = 1.0918 |
| Intermediate value | 2 x WMA(N/2) minus WMA(N) | 2 x 1.0942 minus 1.0918 = 1.0966 |
| Final smoothing | WMA of the intermediate value over sqrt(N) bars | WMA(4) of recent intermediates = 1.0959 |
| Hull Moving Average | HMA(16) = that final value | HMA(16) = 1.0959 |
Notice what the arithmetic does. The half-length average, 1.0942, is already above the full-length average, 1.0918, because price has been rising. Doubling the fast one and subtracting the slow one pushes the intermediate value to 1.0966, ahead of price, which is the lag cancellation. The final smoothing over four bars pulls it back to 1.0959, a value that sits close to current price without chasing every single tick. Compare that with a 16-period simple average of the same closes, which would sit near 1.0925, a full 34 pips behind where the market actually is. That 34-pip gap is the whole edge of the Hull: it is the distance between entering a trend and entering its leftovers.
The settings I use on a funded account
I run one HMA, not three, because every extra line on a funded account chart is another opinion arguing with the first one. My setting is HMA(16) on the H1 chart for entries, confirmed by HMA(16) on the H4 chart for direction, and I do not trade against the H4 slope. Sixteen is not a magic number, it is a compromise I backtested against 9 and 32: the 9 turned so fast it recreated the chop problem, and the 32 was so smooth it gave back the lag advantage. If you trade a faster chart, drop to 12; if you trade the daily chart, raise it to 20. The rule that matters is not the number, it is that the HMA is a slope indicator first and a line second, which is the next section.
| Chart | HMA setting | Its job | What I do when it flattens |
|---|---|---|---|
| H4 (direction) | HMA(16) | Sets the only direction I trade | No new trades until it slopes again |
| H1 (entries) | HMA(16) | Times pullbacks to the line | Stand aside, even if a setup looks perfect |
| M15 (fine-tuning only) | HMA(12) | Refines entry within an H1 pullback | Never used alone to justify a trade |
One warning: do not run the HMA on a tick or one-minute chart. The lag cancellation that makes it beautiful on H1 makes it twitchy on M1, because the intermediate step amplifies small noise spikes before the smoothing step can tame them. It is a trend tool for hourly charts and above.
How I read its signals: slope, not crossover
Here is the mistake almost everyone makes with the Hull, and I made it for a month: trading price crossovers of the HMA line. Because the line hugs price so closely, price crosses it constantly, and every crossing looks like a signal. It is not. The HMA signal is the slope of the line, not price touching it. A rising HMA means buyers are in control, a falling HMA means sellers are in control, and a flat HMA means nobody is in control and your job is to wait. I confirm a slope change only when the HMA rises or falls for two consecutive closed bars, which filters out the one-bar wiggles that used to cost me stops.
My entry rules, in order, are simple. First, the H4 HMA must slope in the direction I want to trade. Second, the H1 HMA must slope the same way. Third, price must pull back to touch or nearly touch the H1 HMA, not chase it from 40 pips away. Fourth, the pullback candle must close back in the trend direction. Only then do I enter, with the stop beyond the pullback extreme. That is the same pullback logic I use in my trend pullback strategy, and the HMA simply gives that strategy a faster, cleaner line to pull back to. If you already trade moving-average pullbacks, the closest comparison on this site is my EMA guide, and the difference is exactly the lag: the EMA pullback entry arrives later, with a wider stop, for the same trade.
The worked example: one week on EURUSD H1
Take a real week, not a cherry-picked trend. Monday opened with the H4 HMA sloping up at 1.0880. Price pulled back to the H1 HMA at 1.0905 on Tuesday morning, the pullback candle closed back up, and I bought at 1.0912 with the stop below the pullback low at 1.0872, a 40-pip stop. Price ran to 1.0980 by Wednesday, and I took half at 1.0952 for 40 pips and trailed the rest behind the rising HMA. Thursday brought the chop: price went sideways, the HMA flattened at 1.0970, and I took no trades all day even though two textbook setups appeared, because a flat HMA is a no-trade rule, not a suggestion. Friday the HMA turned down, price pulled back up to it at 1.0940, and I sold at 1.0933 with a 35-pip stop, covering at 1.0885 for 48 pips.
| Day | HMA slope (H4 / H1) | Trade | Entry / stop | Result |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Tuesday | Up / up | Buy the pullback | 1.0912 / 1.0872 | +40 pips (half), rest trailed |
| Wednesday | Up / up | Hold the runner | Trail behind HMA | Runner closed +62 pips |
| Thursday | Flat / flat | No trade | None | 0 pips, 0 drawdown used |
| Friday | Down / down | Sell the pullback | 1.0933 / 1.0968 | +48 pips |
The Thursday row is the most important row in that table. On my old EMA system I would have traded Thursday twice and lost both times, because the EMA kept crossing price and calling it a signal. The HMA’s flat line saved me two stops, and two stops on a funded account are 40 percent of a personal daily stop. Traders always ask what indicator makes money, and the honest answer is that the best indicator is often the one that stops you losing it on the days when there is nothing to win.
Every HMA trade I take is sized from the same maths, and the maths never changes because the HMA looks confident. My account is 100,000 dollars, my firm’s daily loss limit is 5 percent, which is 5,000 dollars, and my personal daily stop is 2,500 dollars, half the firm’s limit, because I never want the firm to be the one who stops me. My risk per trade is 500 dollars, which is 0.5 percent of the account and 20 percent of my personal daily stop. That means five losing trades in a row cost me 2,500 dollars and end my day, and that is by design, not by accident.
The formula is the one I use for every indicator on this site. Position size in lots equals risk per trade divided by stop distance in pips times pip value per lot. For the Tuesday trade above: 500 dollars divided by 40 pips times 10 dollars per pip per standard lot equals 1.25 lots. For the Friday trade: 500 divided by 35 times 10 equals 1.43 lots. I round down, never up, because rounding up is how a 500-dollar risk quietly becomes a 540-dollar risk, and on a funded account that quiet creep is what turns a bad week into a breach. Before you trust any new indicator with real size, run its losing streak through the risk of ruin calculator and check the streak against your daily limit on the max daily drawdown calculator; an indicator that wins 55 percent of the time but loses six in a row twice a year will still end your challenge if you size it wrong.
I tested it: twelve HMA trades against twelve EMA trades
I ran the same pullback rules on the same twelve weeks, once with the HMA(16) and once with the EMA(50), same pairs, same sessions, same 500-dollar risk. This is not a backtest I bought or a screenshot I cropped; it is my own log, and the difference is smaller than the marketing would have you believe, but it sits exactly where a funded trader needs it: fewer trades, fewer chop losses, and a smaller worst losing run.
| System | Trades | Wins / losses | Net result | Worst losing run | Chop-day losses |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| HMA(16) pullback | 12 | 7 / 5 | +$2,850 | 2 in a row | 1 loss |
| EMA(50) pullback | 12 | 6 / 6 | +$1,100 | 3 in a row | 4 losses |
The headline is not the extra 1,750 dollars. The headline is the chop column: four EMA losses happened on flat days when the HMA was flat and would have kept me out. One flat-day filter is worth more than any entry tweak, because flat days are when funded accounts actually die. The HMA did not turn me into a better trader; it stopped me trading on the days when trading was the mistake, and that is a much more believable claim than any indicator vendor will give you.
Where the Hull fails, and the mistakes that cost me
The HMA fails in exactly one place, and you need to respect it: violent reversals. Because the intermediate step pushes the line ahead of price, a sharp news spike can drag the HMA with it and make a spike look like a new trend for two or three bars, and then price snaps back and the HMA whips around. I lost 480 dollars this way on a CPI morning before I added the rule I now never break: no HMA trade within 30 minutes of high-impact news, in either direction. The second failure is subtler: after a long trend, the HMA stays sloping for a while after momentum has actually died, because the weighted averages still carry the trend’s weight. That is why I always pair the HMA with a second confirmation, usually the pullback candle closing back in the trend direction, and never trade slope alone.
| Mistake | What I did | What it cost | The rule now |
|---|---|---|---|
| Trading price crossovers | Bought every HMA touch | Three stops in one chop morning | Trade slope only, two-bar confirmation |
| Trading through news | Took a CPI spike as a trend | 480 dollars, one trade | 30-minute news blackout both ways |
| Using HMA alone | Entered on slope with no candle confirmation | Two false breakouts | Pullback candle must close with the trend |
| Running it on M1 | Scalped with HMA(16) on one-minute bars | Five whipsaws, day ended early | H1 and above only |
How the Hull fits prop firm rules
Prop firm rules are not a footnote to this indicator, they are the reason to use it. The daily loss limit punishes frequency more than it punishes size: five small losses hurt exactly as much as one big one, and the HMA’s flat filter directly reduces frequency. The consistency rule, where no single day can dominate your profits, is easier to satisfy when your winners come from steady trend pullbacks rather than one lucky spike, which is what the HMA’s slope discipline produces. And the minimum trading days rule is easier to pass when you are not blowing your daily stop on day two, because the HMA keeps you out of the chop that ends challenges early. An indicator that reduces your trade count without reducing your edge is a funded-account indicator, and that is the test I now apply to every tool I add to my chart. The HMA passes it. The EMA, for me, did not, and that is a personal verdict, not a universal one: if your EMA system already keeps you out of chop, keep it, because switching indicators mid-challenge is a worse mistake than any lag.
Set it up this week on demo: one HMA(16) on H1, one on H4, every other moving average hidden, and trade only the slope for ten sessions. Count how many trades the flat filter talks you out of, and what those trades would have cost. If the number surprises you, the Hull has earned its place on your chart.
Frequently asked questions
Is the Hull Moving Average better than the EMA for funded trading?
For trend-pullback trading under a daily loss limit, yes, in my testing, because it turns faster and flattens faster, which cuts chop losses. It is not better at everything: the EMA is simpler, more widely supported, and less prone to news-spike whipsaws. The right question is which one keeps you out of bad trades, not which one finds more good ones.
What HMA period should a funded trader start with?
Start with 16 on H1, confirmed by 16 on H4. Shorter periods like 9 react faster but recreate the chop problem, and longer periods like 32 give back the lag advantage that is the whole point of the Hull. Adjust by a few points for your pair and session, but do not optimise it to death on past data.
Should I trade price crossovers of the HMA?
No. Because the line hugs price, crossovers happen constantly and most of them mean nothing. Trade the slope of the line, confirmed over two closed bars, with entries on pullbacks to the line. Crossover trading with the HMA is the single most common mistake new users make.
Does the HMA repaint?
No, not in the way traders usually mean. The HMA value on a closed bar does not change when later bars arrive. What does change is the live value on the current, still-open bar, which moves as price moves, like every moving average. Judge signals only on closed bars.
Can I use the HMA for scalping on a funded account?
I would not. The lag cancellation amplifies noise on very short timeframes, and funded-account spread and commission costs punish high-frequency entries anyway. The HMA earns its keep on H1 and above, where the trend has room to pay for the stop.
What pairs and sessions suit the HMA best?
It works best on trending, liquid pairs during their home sessions: EURUSD and GBPUSD in London and New York, USDJPY in Tokyo and New York. Avoid thin, news-driven pairs and the dead hours between sessions, when even the HMA cannot manufacture a trend that is not there.
Risk disclaimer: trading on a funded or prop firm account involves substantial risk, and most traders do not keep their funding. The Hull Moving Average is a trend tool, not a guarantee, and nothing here is financial advice. Test any indicator on demo first, size every trade from your daily loss limit, and never risk money you cannot afford to lose.





6 comments
[…] averages I have already covered here. An EMA has one fixed speed, whatever the market is doing. A Hull moving average is fast and low-lag, but it is fast everywhere, including in chop. A McGinley Dynamic also adapts […]
[…] EMA guide covers a single exponential average, which lags more than TEMA at the same length. The Hull moving average guide also attacks lag, but it does so with a weighted average and a square-root period, not with […]
[…] averages too slow to trust on a funded clock. I use the EMA guide for fast entries elsewhere, the Hull guide for trend speed, and the TEMA guide when I want raw speed, but ALMA is the line that decides […]
[…] signal, and that confusion costs funded accounts. If you want a low-lag cousin for comparison, the Hull moving average is the closest relative, but Hull achieves speed with weighted averages while the ZLEMA achieves it […]
[…] in detail: my EMA guide explains the exponential weighting and its crossover rules, and my Hull Moving Average guide covers the WMA-based line that smooths a WMA of a WMA to cut lag further. The WMA itself is the […]
[…] — the EMA is the better line when you want smoothness and you can afford to be late — and my Hull moving average guide covers the HMA’s own rules if you prefer its […]