PropDD

Accumulation Swing Index for Prop Firm Traders: Wilder’s Swing Line, Fitted to Drawdown Rules

By Remi Robin · Updated · 13 min read · Indicators

Accumulation Swing Index ASI line chart settings for prop firm traders

I found the Accumulation Swing Index in the last chapter of a book I had already read twice. Welles Wilder’s 1978 New Concepts in Technical Trading Systems gave me the RSI and the ATR years ago, and I had skipped the chapter after them because the formula looked like homework. Then a funded-account week cost me 1,400 dollars on three breakouts that all failed the next day.

In this article
  1. What the Accumulation Swing Index actually measures
  2. The formula, worked by hand on five EURUSD days
  3. Best settings for prop-firm trading
  4. How to read its signals
  5. My worked trade: the joint break I actually took
  6. Twelve trades with the ASI filter: what the numbers say
  7. ASI vs the Accumulation Distribution Line and OBV
  8. When ASI fails on a funded account
  9. My daily ASI routine
  10. Frequently asked questions

My first attempt nearly put me off it for good. I coded the formula with the limit move set to 1, because forex has no exchange limit move, and the line exploded to four figures in a week. The indicator was not broken; my setting was. This guide covers it on a 100,000 dollar funded account: 5,000 dollar daily loss limit, 10,000 dollar maximum drawdown, 500 dollar risk per trade, and a limit-move proxy of 100 pips on EURUSD, stated openly and never changed mid-test.

What the Accumulation Swing Index actually measures

Most indicators read one thing. The RSI reads closes. The ATR reads ranges. The Accumulation Swing Index reads the relationship between two whole bars: today’s open, high, low and close against yesterday’s. Wilder’s aim was to cut through the noise inside ordinary candlesticks and isolate the swing the market actually made. The Swing Index scores a single day between minus 100 and plus 100. The Accumulation Swing Index adds those daily scores into a running total, so it has no fixed ceiling and no fixed floor.

That makes it a confirmation tool, not an entry system. It does not tell you to buy. It tells you whether the price move you are looking at is supported by the swings underneath it. If price makes a new high and the ASI makes a new high beside it, the move has swing support. If price makes a new high and the ASI makes a lower high, the move is running on closes alone and deserves caution. The line follows the broad direction of price, so it will never catch a turn before price does, but it is very good at exposing the breakouts that are about to fail.

The formula, worked by hand on five EURUSD days

The formula looks worse than it is. There are four pieces: Q, the swing numerator; K, the stretch from the previous close; R, the range divisor; and M, the limit move. The Swing Index is 50 times Q divided by R, times K divided by M. The Accumulation Swing Index is yesterday’s ASI plus today’s Swing Index. That is all of it.

Piece Formula What it means
Q (swing numerator) (C2 – C1) + 0.5 x (C2 – O2) + 0.25 x (C1 – O1) Close change + half today’s body + quarter of yesterday’s body
K (stretch) Larger of |H2 – C1| and |L2 – C1| How far today stretched away from yesterday’s close
R (range divisor) Depends on which of |H2 – C1|, |L2 – C1|, |H2 – L2| is largest Scales the swing by the day’s real range
M (limit move) Exchange limit move; forex proxy 100 pips on EURUSD Scale factor; state it, never change it mid-test
Swing Index SI = 50 x (Q / R) x (K / M) One day’s score, between -100 and +100
ASI ASI = previous ASI + today’s SI The running total; the line you draw trendlines on

R has three cases, decided by whichever of the three distances is largest. If the high-to-previous-close distance is largest, R equals that distance minus half the low-to-previous-close distance plus a quarter of yesterday’s body. If the low distance is largest, the two swap. If the day’s own high-to-low range is largest, R equals the range plus a quarter of yesterday’s body. On EURUSD the range is usually the largest, which is why my five worked days below all fall in the third case. The alphasquawk ASI guide prints the same formula with worked code. Five EURUSD days, worked in pips with M set to 100, ASI starting at zero on the Day 0 baseline bar:

Day Open High Low Close Q K R SI ASI
Day 0 Mon (base) 1.0900 1.0940 1.0880 1.0920 – – – – 0.00
Day 1 Tue 1.0920 1.0960 1.0900 1.0950 50.0 40 65.00 +15.38 15.38
Day 2 Wed 1.0950 1.0985 1.0935 1.0975 45.0 35 57.50 +13.70 29.08
Day 3 Thu 1.0975 1.0990 1.0945 1.0955 -23.8 30 51.25 -6.95 22.13
Day 4 Fri 1.0955 1.0970 1.0930 1.0965 10.0 25 45.00 +2.78 24.91
Day 5 Mon 1.0965 1.1000 1.0960 1.0995 47.5 35 42.50 +19.56 44.47

Day 3 is the whole lesson. Price made a new high at 1.0990 but closed at 1.0955, below Day 2’s close. Q came out at minus 23.8, the Swing Index at minus 6.95, and the ASI fell from 29.08 to 22.13: price printed a higher high while the ASI printed a lower high. That is divergence, and it warned me off the high. Day 5 is the opposite: price closed at 1.0995 and the ASI jumped 19.56 to 44.47, above its old 29.08 high. Price and the ASI broke out together. That is confirmation, and that is the only kind of breakout I pay for now.

Best settings for prop-firm trading

The ASI has no period to optimise and no overbought level to argue about. The one setting that matters is M, the limit move, and on forex it is a proxy, so the rule is to pick it once, write it down, and never change it. I use 100 pips on EURUSD, close to the pair’s average daily range, and I scale it by the market: GBPJPY gets 150 pips, gold gets 30 dollars. Change M halfway through a test and every ASI value before the change becomes incomparable with every value after it.

Setting My value Why
Chart Daily, 08:00 London close Built on daily bars
M (limit move proxy) 100 pips EURUSD Near the pair’s average daily range; documented, never changed
ASI start point Fixed, 60 bars back Same start every test
Trendline on ASI Drawn across the last two ASI swing highs or lows The ASI break is the confirmation, not the trigger
Trigger Daily close beyond the level, ASI beyond its own high Both must break
Filter No entries on NFP, CPI or rate days News bars distort Q and K

The start point is part of the method. Because the ASI is cumulative, two traders with different start dates get different ASI values from the same price data. I start every ASI line 60 daily bars back, and I never compare an ASI value from one start date with one from another. What I compare is the shape: higher highs, lower highs, trendline breaks. The shape survives the start date; the absolute number does not.

How to read its signals

There are three signals, and only the first two ever put me in a trade. The third is a warning that keeps me out. None of them works alone. The ASI confirms price; it never replaces it.

Trendline-break confirmation is the main signal. Draw a trendline across the last two swing highs on the ASI line, and the same line across the last two swing highs on price. When both break on the same daily close, the breakout is confirmed. In my five-day example the ASI trendline ran across the 29.08 high of Day 2; the Day 5 close took price to 1.0995 and the ASI to 44.47. That joint break is my entry trigger.

Divergence is the warning signal. Price makes a new high, the ASI makes a lower high, and the move is running on closes alone. Day 3 did exactly this: price 1.0990 against Day 2’s 1.0985, ASI 22.13 against 29.08. I did not short it; divergence is a warning, not a reversal signal. I stood aside, and the next day confirmed the warning when price faded to 1.0930. The signal is “do not chase”, never “fade it now”.

The third signal is the filter that saves the daily limit. Price breaks a level and the daily close holds above it, but the ASI does not break its own high. The breakout has no swing support, so I do not take it. In my twelve-trade test this filter removed four trades, all losers.

My worked trade: the joint break I actually took

On the Monday of Day 5, EURUSD closed at 1.0995 with the ASI at 44.47, above its old 29.08 high. Price and the ASI had broken together, the news calendar was clear, and my open risk was zero. I entered at the Tuesday open, 1.0990, with the stop below the Day 5 open at 1.0960, a 30 pip stop. At 500 dollars of risk and 10 dollars a pip per lot, the size is 1.66 lots, risking 498 dollars, 10 percent of my 5,000 dollar daily loss limit. Note the rounding: 1.67 lots would risk 501 dollars, one dollar over the cap. I test every ASI trade against the max daily drawdown calculator before I place it.

Leg Price Size Result
Entry 1.0990, joint price and ASI break 1.66 lots Risk 498 dollars, stop 1.0960
Stop 1.0960, below the Day 5 open 30 pips 10 dollars a pip per lot, 1.66 lots
Take profit 1 1.1020, half the position 0.83 lots Plus 249 dollars
Take profit 2 1.1050, rest of the position 0.83 lots Plus 498 dollars
Total Exit complete at 1.1050 1.66 lots Plus 747 dollars, 1.50R on 498 risk

The total was plus 747 dollars, 1.5 times my 498 dollar risk: 249 dollars banked at 1.1020, 498 dollars at 1.1050. Had the stop been hit, the loss would have been 498 dollars, and I would have stopped for the day at my personal daily stop. The ASI did not pick the entry price; the breakout level did. Its job was to say yes, and on Day 5 it said yes loudly, with a 19.56 Swing Index day, the strongest of the five.

Twelve trades with the ASI filter: what the numbers say

I ran the joint-break rule on EURUSD daily for twelve trades, all at 1.66 lots and a 498 dollar risk, with one R counted as 500 dollars. The same twelve signals plus the four the filter removed ran alongside: same winners, four extra losers when the filter is off.

Trade Date Direction Result in R Dollars
1 20 Oct Long +1.5 +750
2 21 Oct Long +1.5 +750
3 22 Oct Short -1.0 -500
4 23 Oct Long +1.0 +500
5 26 Oct Long +1.5 +750
6 27 Oct Short -1.0 -500
7 28 Oct Long +1.0 +500
8 29 Oct Long +1.5 +750
9 30 Oct Short -1.0 -500
10 2 Nov Long +1.0 +500
11 3 Nov Short +1.5 +750
12 4 Nov Long -1.0 -500
Version Trades Wins Net Best day share
ASI filter on 12 8 of 12, 66.7 percent +6.5R, +3,250 dollars 750 of 3,250, 23.1 percent, pass
ASI filter off 16 8 of 16, 50.0 percent +2.5R, +1,250 dollars 750 of 1,250, 60.0 percent, fail
Filter worth 4 trades removed All four were losers +4.0R, +2,000 dollars Consistency fixed by the filter

The filtered test made 3,250 dollars at a 66.7 percent win rate and 0.54R expectancy, and the best day was 750 dollars, 23.1 percent of the net, inside the 30 percent ceiling. The unfiltered test kept four extra losers, netting 1,250 dollars, and the same best day became 60.0 percent of the net, which fails the consistency rule outright. The filter did not make me a better trader; it stopped me trading four breakouts the ASI had refused to confirm. On a 50,000 dollar account the same maths runs at half size: 250 dollars of risk, a 30 pip stop is 0.83 lots risking 249 dollars.

ASI vs the Accumulation Distribution Line and OBV

Three indicators on this site carry the word accumulation, and they measure three different things. The ASI is Wilder’s price-swing line: open, high, low and close only, no volume, built to confirm breakouts and expose divergence. The Accumulation Distribution Line is a volume-weighted money-flow line, and OBV is a crowd-participation line. I use the ASI when the question is “is this breakout real”, the A/D line when the question is “is money flowing with this move”, and OBV when the question is “is the crowd behind this”. They answer different questions, so they do not duplicate each other. Pick the question first, then the line.

When ASI fails on a funded account

The ASI fails in exactly the market it was never built for, and a funded account makes every failure more expensive. First, a range: the ASI line goes flat, trendlines on it break every other day, and each false confirmation costs a full stop. Second, the limit-move proxy: pick M too small and the SI values explode, so every day looks like a breakout; pick it too large and nothing ever confirms. Third, the start date: restart the ASI line mid-test and the values jump. Fourth, news: a CPI bar can print a Q of 80 pips and drag the ASI with it, confirming a move that reverses the next morning. My fixes are plain: no ASI trades in a range, M fixed at 100 pips on EURUSD, the start date fixed at 60 bars back, and no entries on news days.

Three mistakes cause most of those failures. The first is treating the ASI as an oscillator and trading its levels: it has no overbought or oversold level, because it is cumulative and unbounded. A high ASI value means the market has swung up a long way since the start date, not that it is overbought. The second is comparing ASI values across different M settings or start dates, which is comparing two different lines. The third is drawing the ASI trendline on too few points: one swing high is not a trendline.

My daily ASI routine

The routine takes ten minutes. At 08:00 London, after the daily close, I write down the ASI value, the ASI trendline level, the price level and the size before I look at the open position. If price and the ASI have not broken together, there is no trade. If they have, I check the news calendar and the open-risk total first. I check the position once at the New York open and once at the London close, and I never move the stop except to the plan. Every Friday I re-read the log and check three numbers: the best day’s share of the net, under 30 percent; the open risk, under 1,000 dollars per market; and the signals the filter removed. The RSI guide covers Wilder’s other famous indicator, and the ATR position-sizing guide covers sizing for stops wider than 30 pips.

Frequently asked questions

Is the Accumulation Swing Index the same as the Accumulation Distribution Line?

No. The ASI is Wilder’s price-swing line: open, high, low and close only, never volume. The Accumulation Distribution Line is a volume-weighted money-flow line.

What limit move value should I use on forex?

Use a proxy and document it: 100 pips on EURUSD, 150 pips on GBPJPY, 30 dollars on gold. Never change M mid-test, and never compare ASI values computed with different M settings.

Can I trade ASI signals on their own?

No. The ASI is a confirmation tool: it confirms a price breakout or warns that one is unsupported. It has no entry price, no stop and no target of its own. My rule is that price and the ASI must break together on the daily close.

Does ASI work on a 50,000 dollar account?

Yes, at half the numbers: 250 dollars of risk, a 30 pip stop is 0.83 lots risking 249 dollars, still 10 percent of a 2,500 dollar daily limit.

Why does my ASI look different from another trader’s ASI?

Because the ASI is cumulative, so it depends on its start date and its M setting. Two traders with different start dates or M values get different ASI lines from the same price data. Compare the shape, not the absolute number.

Does ASI work on gold and indices?

Yes, with M scaled. Gold’s exchange limit move is 75 dollars in the standard tables; for CFD gold I use a 30 dollar proxy. The formula is identical; only M and the point value change.

Risk disclaimer: Trading leveraged products on a funded account can lead to the loss of your challenge fee and your funded account. The Accumulation Swing Index is a confirmation tool, not a trading system, and its signals can fail in ranging markets and on news days. Past results, including my twelve-trade test, do not guarantee future results. This article is educational only.

Check your own numbers

Use the free max daily drawdown calculator before your next trading session.

Open the calculator

Join the discussion

Your email address will not be published. Please keep it respectful and on topic. Links are not allowed.

Recent articles

Remi Robin
About the author

Remi Robin

Independent forex trader and writer

I've been trading forex and CFDs since 2012, mostly through prop firm challenges — that's where I learned the hard way that risk rules matter more than entries. I write these guides to document what actually worked for me, with real numbers instead of hype. Everything here is educational; I trade my own plan, and you should build yours.

More about this site →