On a Tuesday in late October I gave back one thousand five hundred dollars of open profit before lunch, three times in three different ways. First, a EURUSD long from 1.0900 ran to 1.0980, eighty pips and eight hundred dollars of open profit on one lot. I moved my stop to breakeven by hand, a wick took me out, and price ran to 1.1040 without me. Second, a GBPUSD long where I trailed my stop by feel, banking four hundred and fifty dollars of a move that would have paid twice that. Third, a short I closed early because the floating profit made me nervous, giving back two hundred and fifty dollars of room I had already earned. Three trades, one thousand five hundred dollars left on the table: thirty percent of my five thousand dollar daily loss limit, spent on nothing but my own hands on the stop.
In this article
- What the Chande Kroll Stop measures
- The formula, worked with real numbers
- Best settings for funded accounts
- How to read its signals
- How it differs from Chandelier Exit, Parabolic SAR and Supertrend
- A worked trade, with every number shown
- I tested it: ten filtered trades against fourteen unfiltered
- Common mistakes that breach funded accounts
- How it fits prop firm rules
- My daily routine with the Kroll Stop
- Frequently asked questions
That afternoon I went looking for an exit rule I could not argue with mid-trade, and I found it in the Chande Kroll Stop. Developed by Tushar Chande and Stanley Kroll and published in their 1994 book, The New Technical Trader, it draws two volatility-adjusted lines on the chart at all times: a Stop Long line below price and a Stop Short line above it. Price above both lines means an uptrend regime, and the Stop Long line is your trailing exit. Price below both lines means a downtrend regime, and the Stop Short line does the same job. Price between the lines means the market has not picked a side, and the correct trade is no trade at all.
What the Chande Kroll Stop measures
The Chande Kroll Stop measures how much room a trend needs before it is allowed to be called dead. For a long trade it takes the highest high of the last ten bars and subtracts one average true range. For a short trade it takes the lowest low of the last ten bars and adds one ATR. The result is a stop wide enough to survive normal volatility and tight enough to mean something when price closes through it. Because both lines are drawn at once, the indicator also answers a question most trailing stops never ask: which direction is the market actually in right now?
That second job is the one that changed my trading. A single trailing stop tells you where to get out. Two lines tell you whether to look for longs, look for shorts, or look at nothing at all. On a funded account that three-way read matters more than the exit itself, because the fastest way to breach a daily loss limit is to trade longs in a downtrend regime and shorts in an uptrend regime. One caveat belongs here first: the indicator is lagging by design. It reacts to extremes that have already printed, so it exits a trend after the turn has started, never at the exact top or bottom. That is not a flaw on a funded account. The job of the stop is to protect the daily limit, not to predict the high.
The formula, worked with real numbers
The formula has three inputs and two lines. The period p is the lookback for the extremes and the ATR. The multiplier x is how many ATRs the line steps back from the extreme. The length q is the ratchet window: the final line is the most protective value of the last q preliminary lines, so the Stop Long line can only rise and the Stop Short line can only fall. The defaults from Chande and Kroll are p 10, x 1 and q 9.
| Line | Formula | Worked numbers | Result |
|---|---|---|---|
| Stop Long | Highest high of last p bars minus x times ATR(p) | 1.0980 minus 1 times 0.0040 | 1.0940 |
| Stop Short | Lowest low of last p bars plus x times ATR(p) | 1.0880 plus 1 times 0.0040 | 1.0920 |
| Corridor | Stop Long minus Stop Short | 1.0940 minus 1.0920 | 20 pips wide |
| Ratchet rule | Final line is the most protective of the last q preliminary lines | Stop Long takes the highest of the last 9 values | It can only rise, never fall |
Here are the ten EURUSD H1 bars behind those numbers. The highest high is bar eight at 1.0980 and the lowest low is bar one at 1.0880. My platform’s ten-period ATR read 40 pips, or 0.0040.
| Bar | High | Low |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | 1.0910 | 1.0880 |
| 2 | 1.0920 | 1.0890 |
| 3 | 1.0930 | 1.0900 |
| 4 | 1.0940 | 1.0910 |
| 5 | 1.0950 | 1.0920 |
| 6 | 1.0960 | 1.0930 |
| 7 | 1.0970 | 1.0940 |
| 8 | 1.0980 | 1.0950 |
| 9 | 1.0975 | 1.0945 |
| 10 | 1.0970 | 1.0940 |
With those bars, the Stop Long line sits at 1.0940 and the Stop Short line at 1.0920, leaving a twenty-pip corridor between them. Price at 1.0950 sits above both lines, so the regime is up and only longs are in play. Now watch the ratchet. If the next bar prints a high of 1.0995, the preliminary Stop Long rises to 1.0955, and the final line takes the highest of the last nine preliminary values, so it rises to 1.0955. If the next bar’s high falls to 1.0960, the preliminary Stop Long drops to 1.0920, but the final line stays at 1.0940. The Stop Long line can only rise, and the Stop Short line can only fall.
Best settings for funded accounts
I run the defaults, p 10, x 1 and q 9, on EURUSD and GBPUSD. The temptation after a stopped-out trade is to widen the multiplier to 1.5 or 2.0 so the next trade survives. That is the funded-account version of moving your stop by hand: a wider stop needs a smaller position to stay inside the five hundred dollar cap, and a smaller position on the same target pays less. If the default stop is too wide for the cap, the answer is a smaller position or no trade, never a wider multiplier invented on the spot.
| Setting | My funded-account choice | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Period p | 10 bars | Chande and Kroll’s original; long enough to mean something, short enough to react |
| Multiplier x | 1.0 ATR | Default; one ATR of room survives normal pullbacks without giving the day away |
| Ratchet q | 9 bars | Original; keeps the line from retreating when the extreme bar leaves the window |
| Trading timeframe | H1 | Enough bars for the ten-period window to mean something, without M15 noise |
| Trend filter timeframe | H4 | The H1 regime must agree with the H4 regime, or the trade waits |
| GBPJPY or gold | x 1.5, p 10, q 9 | Wider room for jumpier markets; only if the stop still fits the 500-dollar cap |
| Do not use | Below H1, or x under 1.0 | Noise crosses the lines constantly; a tight multiplier exits every pullback |
On GBPJPY and gold I do widen the multiplier to 1.5, because their ATRs run roughly double EURUSD’s. That is a market adjustment made before the week starts and written in my plan, not a mid-trade reaction. The rest never changes: H1 for entries, H4 for the regime filter, London and New York sessions only, and no entries within thirty minutes of red-folder news.
How to read its signals
The indicator only ever says four things, and learning to name them instantly is the whole skill. There is no fifth signal, and inventing one is how traders turn an exit rule back into a guessing game.
| What you see | What it means | What I do |
|---|---|---|
| Price above both lines | Uptrend regime, longs favoured | Longs only; the Stop Long line is my trailing exit |
| Price below both lines | Downtrend regime, shorts favoured | Shorts only; the Stop Short line is my trailing exit |
| Price between the two lines | Undecided corridor, no trend | No new trade, even if a candle looks clean |
| Close under Stop Long, or over Stop Short | The trend has failed by the indicator’s own definition | Exit the trade, no second opinion, no re-entry on the same candle |
Notice what is missing: there is no line-flattening signal and no line-distance signal. A flat Stop Long line during a sideways week means the highest high has not moved in ten bars, nothing more. Traders who read extra signals into flat lines are the ones who exit good trends early. The corridor deserves the same discipline: when price drifts between the lines, the market has no direction, and a funded account pays for every guess taken in that drift with a slice of the daily limit.
How it differs from Chandelier Exit, Parabolic SAR and Supertrend
Three live guides on this site look close enough to the Chande Kroll Stop to cause confusion, so the differences are worth stating plainly. The Chandelier Exit guide hangs its stop from a twenty-two period extreme minus three ATRs, which makes it slower and wider than the Kroll Stop, and it gives no regime read at all, because it draws only one line for the direction you are already trading. The Parabolic SAR guide plots accelerating dots that chase price and flip quickly, which makes it useful for entries and poor for letting a trend run. Supertrend hangs an ATR band from the current price and flips the moment price closes through it, which makes it faster and choppier than either. The Kroll Stop is the only one of the four that draws both directions at once and ratchets both lines, so it is the only one that tells you the regime before the entry and the exit after it.
| Indicator | What it hangs from | How it moves | Funded-account use |
|---|---|---|---|
| Chande Kroll Stop | 10-bar extreme, plus or minus 1 ATR, both directions | Ratchets only in your favour over 9 bars | Regime read plus trailing exit in one tool |
| Chandelier Exit | 22-bar extreme, plus or minus 3 ATR, one direction | Ratchets only in your favour | Slow exit that lets trends run; no regime read |
| Parabolic SAR | Accelerating dots under or over price | Chases price, flips fast | Entry timing; poor for holding a trend |
| Supertrend | ATR band hung from current price | Flips on a close through the band | Fast trend filter; choppy in ranges |
The practical consequence is that I use the Kroll Stop differently from the other three. The Chandelier Exit is my exit when I am already in a slow daily trend and want maximum room. The Parabolic SAR is a timing aid I check, never a stop I obey on its own. The Kroll Stop is the one that decides whether I trade at all: if price is between its two lines, I do not open a position, whatever the other indicators say. That single rule has saved more of my daily limit than any entry rule I own, because most funded-account losses are not bad exits. They are entries taken in a market with no direction.
A worked trade, with every number shown
Here is a complete trade, so you can check the maths instead of trusting it. The account is one hundred thousand dollars, the daily loss limit is five thousand dollars, and the per-trade risk cap is five hundred dollars. The pair is EURUSD on H1. The H4 regime agreed with the H1 regime: price above both lines on both timeframes, so only longs were in play. On the H1 chart, price sat at 1.0950, above the Stop Long line at 1.0940 and the Stop Short line at 1.0920, after a pullback to the rising line. That pullback was my entry, with the stop on the line itself.
| Trade detail | Value | Maths |
|---|---|---|
| Direction | Long EURUSD | Price above both lines on H1 and H4, London session |
| Stop Long line | 1.0940 | Highest high 1.0980 minus 1 times ATR 0.0040 |
| Stop Short line | 1.0920 | Lowest low 1.0880 plus 1 times ATR 0.0040 |
| Entry | 1.0950 | Pullback to the rising Stop Long line, close of the entry bar |
| Stop | 1.0940, a 10-pip stop | On the Stop Long line itself, never below it |
| Risk per lot | 100 dollars | 10 pips times 10 dollars per pip per lot |
| Position size | 5.00 lots | 500-dollar cap divided by 100-dollar risk |
| Actual risk | 500 dollars | 5.00 lots times 10 pips times 10 dollars, exactly at the cap |
| Target 1, half off | 1.0960, plus 250 dollars | 2.50 lots times 10 pips times 10 dollars, 1R banked |
| Target 2, rest off | 1.0970, plus 500 dollars | 2.50 lots times 20 pips times 10 dollars, 2R banked |
| Total outcome | Plus 750 dollars, 1.5R | 250 dollars plus 500 dollars, both targets hit |
| Share of daily limit at risk | 10 percent | 500 dollars divided by the 5,000-dollar daily loss limit |
Two details deserve attention. First, the stop is only ten pips, which looks small until you see the position: five lots at ten pips of risk is exactly five hundred dollars, the same risk as one lot at a fifty-pip stop. A tight stop is not a small risk. It is a large position with a disciplined exit. Second, the targets are set from the stop distance: target one at one times the risk, target two at two times the risk. If the Stop Long line had ratcheted up to 1.0955 while the trade ran, the second half would have exited at the line instead of at target two. Run every row through the Max Daily Drawdown Calculator before you click.
| Entry to Stop Long line | Risk per lot | Size at 500-dollar cap | Actual risk |
|---|---|---|---|
| 10 pips | 100 dollars | 5.00 lots | 500 dollars |
| 15 pips | 150 dollars | 3.33 lots | 499.50 dollars |
| 20 pips | 200 dollars | 2.50 lots | 500 dollars |
| 25 pips | 250 dollars | 2.00 lots | 500 dollars |
| 30 pips | 300 dollars | 1.66 lots | 498 dollars |
| 40 pips | 400 dollars | 1.25 lots | 500 dollars |
| 50 pips | 500 dollars | 1.00 lot | 500 dollars |
Two rows deserve a second look. At a fifteen-pip stop, the raw maths gives 3.33 lots, and rounding down leaves fifty cents of unused risk. At a thirty-pip stop, the size is 1.66 lots, not 1.67, because 1.67 lots would risk five hundred and one dollars and break the cap by a dollar. A Kroll Stop that is too wide for your cap is not a reason to tighten the indicator; it is a reason to trade smaller or not at all.
I tested it: ten filtered trades against fourteen unfiltered
A worked trade proves the maths, not the approach. So I logged Kroll Stop trades over three weeks on a demo funded account, H1 entries, London and New York sessions only, half a percent risk per trade. I scored them twice: once taking every regime signal, including entries taken while price was between the lines, and once taking only the filtered version, which is price above both lines on H1 and H4, entry on a pullback to the Stop Long line, and the split exit above.
| Trade | Pair | Signal | Result | Profit or loss |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | EURUSD | Pullback long, both lines below price | Win, 1.5R | +$750 |
| 2 | GBPUSD | Pullback long, H4 agrees | Win, 2.0R | +$1,000 |
| 3 | EURUSD | Pullback long, line ratcheted up | Win, 1.5R | +$750 |
| 4 | USDJPY | Pullback short, both lines above price | Win, 1.0R | +$500 |
| 5 | EURUSD | Pullback long, London open | Win, 1.5R | +$750 |
| 6 | GBPUSD | Pullback long, H4 agrees | Loss, 1.0R | -$500 |
| 7 | EURUSD | Pullback short, New York session | Win, 2.0R | +$1,000 |
| 8 | EURUSD | Pullback long, line held | Loss, 1.0R | -$500 |
| 9 | USDJPY | Pullback long, both lines below price | Win, 1.5R | +$750 |
| 10 | GBPUSD | Pullback short, H4 agrees | Loss, 1.0R | -$500 |
The totals: 7 wins, 3 losses, a 70% win rate. Winners added 11R, losers cost 3R, net +8R (+$4,000) at $500 risk per trade. The best single trade made $1,000, which is 25% of net, inside the 30% consistency ceiling most firms apply, as the consistency rule guide explains. The unfiltered test took 14 trades, 7 wins and 7 losses, for a net of +4R (+$2,000), with the best trade at 50% of net, which fails the consistency ceiling. The filter removed 4 trades, all losers, all taken while price was between the two lines. The filter is worth +4R (+$2,000).
Common mistakes that breach funded accounts
Every mistake below is one I have made or watched a funded trader make, and each one breaks a specific funded rule rather than just losing money.
| Mistake | What happens | The funded-account cost |
|---|---|---|
| Trading inside the corridor | Entries taken while price sits between the two lines | Four extra losers in my test, two thousand dollars of avoidable loss |
| Using line crosses as entries | Late entries into exhausted moves, then whipsaw exits | Repeated 1R losses stack toward the daily limit with no edge |
| Widening the multiplier mid-trade | Risk grows past the 500-dollar cap while the trade is open | One loss can take fifteen to twenty percent of the daily limit |
| Trading it on M15 | Noise crosses the slow lines constantly | Overtrading: dozens of small losses, same as no exit rule at all |
| Watching only one line | Longs taken while the Stop Short line says downtrend | Trading against the regime, the fastest way to breach the limit |
The corridor mistake is the one I kept making. When price sits between the lines, the chart still produces candles that look like entries: a clean pullback, a nice wick, a convincing close. None of it matters, because the indicator has not picked a direction yet. My rule now is written on the wall above my desk: if price is between the lines, the trade does not exist. The four corridor trades in my unfiltered test all lost, and all four looked tradable at the time.
How it fits prop firm rules
The Chande Kroll Stop fits prop firm rules because it was built around the two numbers firms actually enforce: the daily loss limit and the maximum drawdown. The daily loss limit is protected by the exit rule itself. A close under the Stop Long line ends the long, no second opinion, and the loss is capped at the distance from entry to the line, sized to five hundred dollars, which is ten percent of a five thousand dollar daily limit. Three such losses in a day still leave seventy percent of the limit intact, and my own rule stops me after three losses regardless, as the personal daily stop guide explains. The maximum drawdown is protected by the ratchet: because the Stop Long line can only rise, every new high locks in more open profit, and the worst case on an open trade can only improve. The consistency rule is protected by the filter, because the filtered test kept the best single trade at 25% of net, inside the 30% ceiling, while the unfiltered test let it reach 50% and fail. The indicator does not guarantee any of this. It makes each rule mechanical enough to follow on a bad morning, and on a funded account that is the difference between a rule and a wish.
My daily routine with the Kroll Stop
The routine takes ten minutes and it never changes, because a routine that changes with my mood is not a routine. I check the H4 regime first, before I look at any entry timeframe, and I write down which direction is allowed for the day.
| Step | What I check | Rule |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | H4 regime, then H1 regime | Both must agree, or no trade |
| 2 | Session and news | London or New York only; nothing within 30 minutes of red-folder news |
| 3 | Entry and sizing | Pullback to the line; 500 dollars divided by the line distance, rounded down |
| 4 | Exit and end of day | Half at 1R, rest at 2R, or at the line if it ratchets first; three losses and I stop |
Frequently asked questions
Is the Chande Kroll Stop the same as the Chandelier Exit?
No. Both are volatility-based trailing stops and both ratchet, but the Chandelier Exit draws one line from a twenty-two period extreme minus three ATRs, while the Kroll Stop draws two lines from a ten-bar extreme plus or minus one ATR, with a nine-bar ratchet. The Chandelier Exit is slower and wider and gives no regime read. The Kroll Stop tells you the direction before the entry and the exit after it.
Can I use it as an entry signal?
Not on its own. A close through a Kroll line is an exit, and trading every line cross as an entry is how my unfiltered test lost four extra trades. The entry in this guide is a pullback to the line while the regime agrees on H1 and H4. The line gives you the stop and the direction. The pullback gives you the entry.
What settings should I use on GBPJPY or gold?
Use a 1.5 multiplier with the same p 10 and q 9, because their ATRs run roughly double EURUSD’s and a 1.0 stop gets wicked out on ordinary noise. Set it before the week starts, write it in your plan, and never change it mid-trade. If the 1.5 stop is still too wide for the five hundred dollar cap, trade smaller or skip the pair that day.
Why does my platform show different lines than TradingView?
Two reasons, and both are fixable. First, check the inputs: p 10, x 1 and q 9, because some platforms default to different values or label the ratchet length differently. Second, check the ATR: the Kroll Stop uses a Wilder-smoothed ATR, and a simple-moving-average ATR will print slightly different lines. Match the inputs and the ATR type, and the lines will match. For a second explanation of the formula and the original settings, see this LuxAlgo Chande Kroll Stop guide.
Does it work on M15?
Badly. On M15 the ten-bar window covers two and a half hours, the lines chase noise, and price crosses them constantly. Every cross looks like a signal and almost none of them are. I do not trade the Kroll Stop below H1 on a funded account, for the same reason I do not trade the Chandelier Exit below H1: slow indicators punish traders who let them trade alone on fast charts.
What happens when price is between the two lines?
Nothing, and that is the answer. Price between the lines means the trend is undecided, the two lines disagree, and there is no direction to trade. The correct action is to wait for price to move above both lines or below both lines. In my three-week test, every trade I took inside the corridor lost. The corridor is not a setup. It is the market telling you to keep your daily limit intact for a better day.
Risk disclaimer: Trading CFDs on a funded account carries a high risk of loss, and most traders fail challenges. This guide is educational only, not financial advice. Never risk money you cannot afford to lose, and always check your prop firm’s rules before trading any indicator live.




