I lost 500 dollars on a pattern I had named correctly and traded wrongly. EURUSD was falling, three candles printed in a red-green-red sequence, and I bought the moment the third candle closed — because the pattern had a bullish name and I wanted the reversal. Price fell straight through the level the next morning. The pattern was a stick sandwich, and I had skipped the one rule that makes it tradeable: the two outer candles must close at the same price, and price must then break above the third candle before you buy. A name is not a signal. An equal close plus a break is.
In this article
- What a Stick Sandwich Actually Is
- Why the Equal Closes Matter More Than the Colours
- The Six Rules of the Strategy
- Entry, Stop Loss and Take Profit
- Position Sizing Under a Daily Loss Limit
- The Worked Example, Candle by Candle
- I Tested It: Strict Rules Against Loose Rules
- When the Strategy Fails
- How It Fits Prop Firm Rules
- My Daily Routine for This Strategy
- Frequently Asked Questions
A stick sandwich is a three-candle pattern. The middle candle is the opposite colour to the two candles on either side, the outer candles have larger ranges than the middle one, and — the detail most guides mention and then ignore — the first and third candles close at the same price. That shared close is a level the market has now defended twice. This article is the full plan: the exact three-candle rules, why the equal closes matter more than the colours, the entry, stop and target maths, and a twelve-trade test that shows what the strict version is worth on a funded account.
What a Stick Sandwich Actually Is
The pattern has three candles, and every one of them has a job:
| Candle | What it must do | What it means |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Long red body, closing lower in a downtrend | Sellers in control, first close marked |
| 2 | Smaller green body, opening above candle 1’s close | Buyers push back for one session |
| 3 | Red body, closing at exactly candle 1’s close | Sellers return — but cannot close below the first close |
Read the three candles as a single sentence. Sellers drive price down and close at 1.0900. Buyers lift it for a session. Sellers drive it back down — and stop at exactly 1.0900 again. Two separate selling efforts, same closing price. That is not a coincidence to trade on its own, but it is a level worth watching, because the market has now told you twice where selling runs out of steam. For a second, independent description of the same three-candle structure, see Babypips’ stick sandwich definition.
Why the Equal Closes Matter More Than the Colours
Most traders check the colours — red, green, red — and stop there. That is how my 500-dollar loss happened, because plenty of red-green-red sequences are just noise in a downtrend. The colours only say that buyers interrupted sellers for one candle. The equal closes say something stronger: sellers had two chances to close below 1.0900 and failed both times.
- Without equal closes, there is no stick sandwich — just three candles in a falling market.
- With equal closes, you have a defended level: the shared close of candles 1 and 3.
- The level only becomes a trade when price breaks above the third candle’s high. Until then, it is a level to watch, not a position to hold.
- My tolerance is 5 pips: if the third candle’s close is within 5 pips of the first candle’s close, I accept it as equal. More than 5 pips apart, the level is not a level, and I skip the pattern.
That 5-pip tolerance is my own tightening of the textbook rule, which demands an exact match. On a 1-hour chart, spreads and wicks make a literally identical close rarer than the textbooks admit, and rejecting every pattern over a 2-pip difference would leave almost nothing to trade. But a 10-pip gap is not an equal close either — it is two different levels pretending to be one.
The Six Rules of the Strategy
These are the rules I trade, in order, with no exceptions:
| Rule | Exact condition |
|---|---|
| 1. Trend | Extended downtrend first — at least 80 pips of decline or four lower closes on the 1-hour chart or higher |
| 2. Location | Pattern forms at a support level, a prior swing low, a round number, or a Fibonacci retracement level |
| 3. The sandwich | Three candles: red, green, red; the middle candle’s range is smaller than both outer candles’ ranges |
| 4. The equal closes | Candle 3’s close within 5 pips of candle 1’s close |
| 5. The break | Price breaks above candle 3’s high — entry on a buy stop 5 pips above that high, never at candle 3’s close |
| 6. Session filter | Trade only the London session (07:00–11:00 GMT) or the New York session (13:30–16:00 GMT) |
Rule 5 is the rule I broke on my losing trade, and it is the most important one in the list. Entering at the third candle’s close means buying while sellers are still in control of the session. Waiting for the break above the third candle’s high means buyers have already proved they can push past the last red candle. On a funded account, that proof is worth more than the few pips of entry price you give up by waiting.
Entry, Stop Loss and Take Profit
Once all six rules pass, the trade writes itself:
- Entry: on a buy stop 5 pips above the third candle’s high.
- Stop loss: 10 pips below the pattern’s lowest low — usually the third candle’s low or the first candle’s low, whichever is lower. If price returns there, the defended level has failed.
- Take profit 1: 1R from entry — close half the position, bank the first win, move the stop to breakeven.
- Take profit 2: 2R from entry — close the rest at the next resistance level.
On the worked trade below: entry 1.0950, stop 1.0875 (pattern low 1.0885 minus a 10-pip buffer), so the stop distance is 75 pips. Take profit 1 at 1.1025 (75 pips, 1R) and take profit 2 at 1.1100 (150 pips, 2R). Half at 1R plus half at 2R gives 1.5R on the full position — the standard outcome this plan is built around.
Position Sizing Under a Daily Loss Limit
My funded account is 100,000 dollars with a 5% firm daily loss limit — 5,000 dollars. My personal rule, set well below the firm limit, is 500 dollars of risk per trade. That is the number every size below is built on, and it is why one losing trade can never breach the firm rule on its own. I wrote about setting that personal ceiling in my guide to setting a personal daily stop below the firm limit.
The sizing formula is simple:
| Input | Value |
|---|---|
| Risk per trade | 500 dollars |
| Stop distance | 75 pips (entry 1.0950 minus stop 1.0875) |
| Pip value per lot (EURUSD) | 10 dollars |
| Position size | 500 divided by (75 times 10) = 0.66 lots |
| Actual risk | 0.66 times 75 times 10 = 495 dollars |
I always round down, never up. Rounding 0.666 to 0.67 would risk 503 dollars; rounding down to 0.66 risks 495. A few dollars of risk is not worth breaking a rule I set for myself. If you want the arithmetic checked before you trade, the max daily drawdown calculator runs the same daily-limit maths.
| Stop distance (pips) | Lots at 500 dollars risk | Actual risk (dollars) |
|---|---|---|
| 30 | 1.66 | 498 |
| 40 | 1.25 | 500 |
| 50 | 1.00 | 500 |
| 60 | 0.83 | 498 |
| 75 | 0.66 | 495 |
| 100 | 0.50 | 500 |
One hard guardrail: if the stop distance is wider than 100 pips, the pattern formed in a volatility spike or the low is too far away — skip it. A stick sandwich that needs a 130-pip stop is not a better trade, it is a different trade, and it does not fit a funded account at 0.5% risk.
The Worked Example, Candle by Candle
The trade, exactly as it printed on the EURUSD 1-hour chart:
| Candle | Open | High | Low | Close |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 (red, long) | 1.0960 | 1.0965 | 1.0890 | 1.0900 |
| 2 (green, smaller) | 1.0910 | 1.0950 | 1.0905 | 1.0945 |
| 3 (red, equal close) | 1.0940 | 1.0945 | 1.0885 | 1.0900 |
Check the rules: candle 1 is a 60-pip red body closing at 1.0900. Candle 2 is a 35-pip green body, smaller in range (45 pips) than candle 1’s range (75 pips), opening above candle 1’s close. Candle 3 is red, with a 60-pip range, and closes at 1.0900 — exactly candle 1’s close, so the equal-close rule passes with zero tolerance used. The pattern low is candle 3’s low of 1.0885. Entry on a buy stop 5 pips above candle 3’s high of 1.0945 gives 1.0950; stop 10 pips below the pattern low gives 1.0875. Take profit 1 at 1.1025 banks 247 dollars on half the position (0.33 lots times 75 pips times 10 dollars), the stop moves to breakeven, and take profit 2 at 1.1100 banks 495 dollars on the rest (0.33 lots times 150 pips times 10 dollars) — 742 dollars total, 1.5R on 495 dollars of risk.
I Tested It: Strict Rules Against Loose Rules
I backtested stick-sandwich candidates on EURUSD and GBPUSD 1-hour charts two ways: twelve candidates with all six rules enforced, and fifteen candidates with the equal-close tolerance, the break confirmation and the session filter removed — entering at the third candle’s close instead. The loose set is larger because removing the filters admitted three extra candidates that the strict rules would have rejected. Same 500-dollar risk, same 1R/2R exits:
| Version | Wins / Losses | Net result | Best single trade |
|---|---|---|---|
| Full rules (strict) | 8 wins / 4 losses | Plus 6R = 3,000 dollars | 742 dollars (24.7% of net) |
| Loose version (no equal-close/break/session checks) | 6 wins / 9 losses | Zero = 0 dollars | 742 dollars (a break-even set) |
The filtered winners were 6 trades at the full 1.5R plus 2 trades at 0.5R (take profit 1 only, then breakeven) — 10R of wins against 4R of losses, net 6R. The loose set won 6 times at 1.5R (9R total) against 9 full losses (9R), net zero. The strict rules were worth 6R, or 3,000 dollars, across the two sets. More importantly for a funded trader, the filtered best trade was 24.7% of net profit — inside the 30% consistency ceiling most firms apply — while the loose set’s losers clustered on patterns whose outer closes were 10–20 pips apart, which were never defended levels at all. If your firm runs a consistency rule, check the maths first with the prop firm consistency rule calculator before you size up.
A five-trade slice from the filtered set shows the shape of the plan in practice:
| Trade | Outcome | Result (dollars) |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Full winner, both targets | +742 |
| 2 | Full loser, stop hit | -495 |
| 3 | Full winner, both targets | +742 |
| 4 | Take profit 1 only, then breakeven | +247 |
| 5 | Full winner, both targets | +742 |
| Total | 4 wins / 1 loss | +1,978 (about 4R) |
When the Strategy Fails
Stick sandwiches fail in predictable ways, and each failure has a tell:
| Failure mode | What it looks like | The defence |
|---|---|---|
| Unequal closes | Candle 3 closes more than 5 pips from candle 1’s close | Skip — without a shared level, there is no pattern |
| Buying the close | Entering at candle 3’s close instead of waiting for the break above its high | Wait for the break — the close is sellers’ territory |
| Mid-range pattern | Three candles form in the middle of a range, no real downtrend before them | Skip — no trend, no reversal to trade |
| News spike | The break above candle 3’s high is a news-driven spike that reverses within an hour | No trades 30 minutes either side of red-folder news |
| Second leg down | Price takes TP1, then falls through the breakeven stop | Accept the 0.5R — breakeven stops are a feature, not a bug |
The most expensive failure is the one I made: confusing the pattern’s name with a signal. Some guides label this pattern bullish and some flip the labels entirely, calling the downtrend version a continuation. Ignore the label. Trade only the structure — downtrend, smaller middle candle, equal outer closes, break above the third candle’s high — and let price confirm the direction instead of a name.
How It Fits Prop Firm Rules
Three firm rules decide whether this strategy survives contact with a real funded account:
- Daily loss limit: at 500 dollars per trade, even two consecutive full losses leave 4,000 dollars of the 5,000-dollar firm limit untouched. The plan never risks the day on one pattern.
- Consistency rule: the 1R/2R split exit keeps any single trade near 25% of a typical winning set’s net profit, inside a 30% ceiling. Chasing a 3R runner on one trade is how traders break this rule.
- Drawdown: stops sit below a visible pattern low, not at an arbitrary distance, so the worst normal loss is the planned 495 dollars — no widening, no averaging down, no second entry after a stop-out on the same pattern.
The strategy also sits cleanly in the reversal family on this site. Its three-candle cousin is the morning star, which reverses with a gapped middle candle instead of equal outer closes. Its five-candle cousin is the ladder bottom, which needs a three-candle descent plus a shadowed fourth candle. Its two-candle cousin is the three inside up, which demands a confirming third candle inside the first body — and the closest relative of all, the harami pattern, differs in exactly one respect: its second candle is the opposite colour AND closes inside the first body, while the stick sandwich’s second candle is smaller but its third candle must return to the first close. And if you want the opposite kind of signal — a trend-continuation entry rather than a reversal — my trend pullback plan covers that side.
My Daily Routine for This Strategy
| Time (GMT) | Action |
|---|---|
| 06:45 | Mark support levels, prior swing lows and round numbers on EURUSD and GBPUSD 1-hour charts |
| 07:00–11:00 | London session: watch for red-green-red sequences forming at marked levels |
| On candle 3 | Measure candle 3’s close against candle 1’s close; more than 5 pips apart means no pattern, no debate |
| After candle 3 | Place a buy stop 5 pips above candle 3’s high; no fill means no trade |
| After TP1 | Move stop to breakeven, close half, walk away until TP2 or the stop fills |
| 13:30–16:00 | New York session: same rules, same levels, maximum two trades per day |
| End of day | Log the pattern, the close gap in pips and the outcome — the log is what proved the equal-close rule’s worth |
Two trades per day is a hard cap, and in practice this pattern rarely offers even one. It is rare by nature — that is a feature, not a flaw. A strategy that fires twice a week with a real edge beats a strategy that fires twice a day on noise, because every extra trade on a funded account is another chance to breach a rule that has nothing to do with your skill.
Frequently Asked Questions
Do the outer closes have to match to the pip?
In the textbooks, yes. In my trading, within 5 pips counts as equal. A 2-pip difference on a 1-hour chart is spread and timing, not a different level. A 10-pip difference is a different level, and I skip the pattern.
Can I trade the mirror pattern in an uptrend?
Yes, with every rule flipped: green, red, green, with the first and third green candles closing at the same price, and entry on a sell stop 5 pips below the third candle’s low. I trade it less often, because shorting into an uptrend’s equal closes punishes hesitation more than buying exhaustion bottoms.
How is a stick sandwich different from a harami?
A harami is two candles: a long candle followed by a smaller opposite-colour candle that closes inside the first body. A stick sandwich is three candles, and its signal is not the second candle at all — it is the third candle returning to the first candle’s close. The harami asks whether buyers appeared; the stick sandwich asks whether sellers failed twice at the same price.
What if price breaks above the third candle’s high but closes back below it?
A break that closes back below the third candle’s high is a failed break, and my buy stop would already have filled. That is what the stop below the pattern low is for — the loss is capped at 495 dollars, and I do not re-enter the same pattern.
Does this pattern work on lower timeframes?
It prints on every timeframe, but below 1-hour the three-candle structure forms constantly out of noise — too many near-equal closes, too many failed breaks, and spreads eat the smaller stops. On a funded account, 1-hour and 4-hour are the only timeframes I trust for this pattern.
Why wait for the break instead of buying the third candle’s close?
Because the third candle’s close is sellers’ territory — the session just closed red. Buying there paid me a 500-dollar lesson. The break above the third candle’s high is the first moment buyers have actually won a session boundary, and on a funded account that proof is worth a few pips of entry price.
Risk disclaimer: Trading leveraged products on a funded account carries a high risk of loss, including the loss of your challenge fee and account. This article describes my own routine for education only and is not financial advice. Never risk more than your firm’s daily loss limit allows, and never trade a pattern you have not backtested yourself.





2 comments
[…] line’s confirmation is a close beyond the second candle, not inside the first. The Stick Sandwich uses three candles with equal outer closes, while a counterattack line uses two candles with equal […]
[…] with equal lows, usually with wicks; a matching low is about equal closes, not equal lows. My stick sandwich guide and my homing pigeon guide trade the cousins — neither is this […]