I lost 500 dollars on a counterattack line on a day when I saw the pattern perfectly and traded it completely wrong. It was a Tuesday in London session, EURUSD had been falling all morning, and the second candle of the pair closed at exactly the same price as the first. I read that as a reversal, bought immediately at the close, and watched price slide another 90 pips before my stop was hit. The pattern was real. My trade was not, because I had skipped the two things that make a counterattack line tradeable on a funded account: the gap open that proves the counterattack actually happened, and a confirmation candle that proves the old trend has actually stopped. This article is the version I trade now, with both filters in place before any money goes in.
In this article
- What a counterattack line actually is
- The two mirror versions, side by side
- The six rules I trade, in order
- Entry, stop loss and targets
- The worked trade, candle by candle
- Position sizing under a 500-dollar daily limit
- What the strict rules are actually worth
- When the strategy fails, and how I recognise it early
- How counterattack lines fit the funded rules
- How it differs from the patterns it resembles
- My daily routine for this pattern
- Frequently asked questions
Counterattack lines, also called meeting lines, are a two-candle reversal pattern. The first candle runs with the trend. The second candle opens with a gap against the trend, then fights all the way back to close at exactly the same price as the first candle’s close. That equal close is the whole story of the pattern: everything the trend gained in the first candle, the counterattacking side took back in the second. It is a stalemate printed on the chart, and stalemates at the end of a trend are worth watching. But a stalemate is not a reversal by itself, and on a funded account, where one bad day can end a challenge, the difference between watching and trading matters more than the pattern itself.
What a counterattack line actually is
A counterattack line needs two candles and one exact relationship between them. In a bullish counterattack, which appears at the end of a downtrend, the first candle is long and black. The second candle gaps down at the open, meaning it opens below the first candle’s close, and then climbs back to close at exactly the first candle’s close. In a bearish counterattack, which appears at the end of an uptrend, the mirror image applies: a long white candle, a second candle that gaps up at the open, and a close back at exactly the first candle’s close. In both cases the second candle erases the first candle’s progress without going beyond it. The trend pushed, the other side pushed back just as far, and the market closed the argument in a draw.
The pattern is rare, and that rarity is part of its value. For the textbook definition, see the Synapse Trading guide to bullish and bearish counterattack lines, which covers the same two-candle structure and its confirmation requirement. Most two-candle pairs do not have equal closes, and most equal closes do not come with a gap open. When both conditions land together at the end of a real trend, something has changed in the balance of buyers and sellers. The catch, which my Tuesday loss taught me, is that a draw can also be a pause before the trend resumes. That is why this strategy never trades the pattern alone: it trades the pattern plus a gap, plus a confirmation, plus a level, and only then a position sized to the daily loss limit.
The two mirror versions, side by side
| Feature | Bullish counterattack | Bearish counterattack |
|---|---|---|
| Trend before it | Downtrend, at least 5 falling candles or a clear swing low forming | Uptrend, at least 5 rising candles or a clear swing high forming |
| First candle | Long black candle, body at least 40 pips on EURUSD H1 | Long white candle, body at least 40 pips on EURUSD H1 |
| Second candle open | Gaps down, opening at least 10 pips below the first close | Gaps up, opening at least 10 pips above the first close |
| Second candle close | Exactly at the first close, within 2 pips tolerance | Exactly at the first close, within 2 pips tolerance |
| What it means | Buyers absorbed a full selling push and returned price to the starting line | Sellers absorbed a full buying push and returned price to the starting line |
| Trade direction | Long only, after confirmation | Short only, after confirmation |
Note the tolerance honestly: in a continuous forex market, true gaps are session opens and weekend opens, not every candle. On an H1 chart I accept a second candle that opens at least 10 pips beyond the first close in the trend’s direction and then closes back at that close. Closes 3 pips or more away from the first close are not counterattack lines at all, no matter how good the rest of the picture looks. Loosening that rule was the first filter I removed on my losing Tuesday, and it is the filter I never remove now.
The six rules I trade, in order
| Rule | The check | Why it exists |
|---|---|---|
| 1. Real trend first | At least 5 candles in one direction, or a swing that has run 150 pips or more | Without a trend to reverse, an equal close is just chop |
| 2. Long first candle | Body of 40 pips or more on EURUSD H1 | A small first candle means no momentum was absorbed |
| 3. Genuine gap open | Second candle opens at least 10 pips beyond the first close, against the trend | The gap is the proof of the counterattack, not the close alone |
| 4. Equal close | Second close within 2 pips of the first close | This is the definition of the pattern; anything wider is a different pattern |
| 5. Confirmation candle | Next candle closes beyond the second candle’s high (bullish) or low (bearish) | Stops me buying a pause that resumes the trend |
| 6. No news in the window | No red-flag news for the pair in the 30 minutes before or after entry | News can print a perfect pattern and then erase it in one candle |
Rule 5 is the one that would have saved my Tuesday trade. The candle after my pattern closed lower, not higher, which meant the counterattack had failed before I even entered. I entered anyway because the pattern looked so clean. Clean patterns that fail confirmation are failed patterns, and funded accounts do not pay for beautiful failures.
Entry, stop loss and targets
For a bullish counterattack, I enter long 5 pips above the second candle’s high once the confirmation candle has closed above it. The stop goes 10 pips below the second candle’s low, which is the lowest point the counterattack reached. That placement is deliberate: if price falls back below the counterattack’s low, the buyers who supposedly took control have lost the level, and the thesis is dead. For a bearish counterattack, the mirror applies: enter short 5 pips below the second candle’s low after a confirming close below it, stop 10 pips above the second candle’s high.
Targets are split, because a reversal that has just been confirmed deserves both a quick bank and room to run. Half the position closes at 1R, which is the same distance as the stop. The rest runs to 1.5R blended, meaning the full position averages 1.5 times the risk if both targets hit. I do not chase a 2R or 3R target on this pattern: the pattern’s own statistics are modest, and a funded account survives on banked 1.5R wins, not on heroic targets that give back open profit.
| Level | Bullish counterattack | Bearish counterattack |
|---|---|---|
| Entry | 5 pips above second candle high, after confirmation close | 5 pips below second candle low, after confirmation close |
| Stop loss | 10 pips below second candle low | 10 pips above second candle high |
| Target 1 (half out) | 1R above entry | 1R below entry |
| Target 2 (rest out) | 2R above entry, giving 1.5R blended | 2R below entry, giving 1.5R blended |
| Invalidation | Any close back below the second candle low before entry | Any close back above the second candle high before entry |
The worked trade, candle by candle
The example below is EURUSD on H1, from a downtrend that had run from 1.1020 down to 1.0880. The first candle opened at 1.0950 and closed at 1.0880, a 70-pip black body. The second candle opened at 1.0850, a full 30 pips below the first close, which clears the 10-pip gap rule comfortably. It then climbed all day and closed at 1.0880, exactly the first candle’s close, with a high of 1.0895 and a low of 1.0845. The confirmation candle closed at 1.0910, above the second candle’s high, so the trade was on.
| Candle | Open | Close | What it proves |
|---|---|---|---|
| First, black | 1.0950 | 1.0880 | Trend candle, 70-pip body, clears the 40-pip minimum |
| Second, white | 1.0850 | 1.0880 | Gap down 30 pips, then a full return to the first close |
| Confirmation | 1.0885 | 1.0910 | Closes above the second high of 1.0895, thesis confirmed |
Entry was 1.0900, 5 pips above the second candle’s high of 1.0895. The stop was 1.0835, 10 pips below the second candle’s low of 1.0845, giving a 65-pip stop. Target 1 was 1.0965, 65 pips above entry, and target 2 was 1.1030, 130 pips above entry. Price hit target 1, then target 2, and the trade banked the full blended 1.5R. The arithmetic is in the next section, and it is the arithmetic that decides the size, not the excitement of the pattern.
Position sizing under a 500-dollar daily limit
My funded account rule is simple: no single trade risks more than 500 dollars, which is the daily loss limit on the account I trade for this strategy. The formula never changes, whatever the pattern:
| Step | Calculation | Result |
|---|---|---|
| Risk per trade | Daily limit, fixed | 500 dollars |
| Stop distance | Entry 1.0900 minus stop 1.0835 | 65 pips |
| Pip value | EURUSD, standard lot | 10 dollars per pip per lot |
| Position size | 500 divided by (65 x 10) | 0.76 lots, rounded down |
| Actual risk | 0.76 x 65 x 10 | 494 dollars |
| Target 1, half out | 0.38 lots x 65 pips x 10 | 247 dollars |
| Target 2, rest out | 0.38 lots x 130 pips x 10 | 494 dollars |
| Total win | 247 + 494 | 741 dollars, 1.5R |
Rounding down is not modesty, it is the rule that keeps the daily limit intact. A size of 0.77 lots would risk 500.50 dollars, which is over the limit by itself. The same grid, applied to other stop distances, is how I size every counterattack trade without recalculating from scratch at the screen:
| Stop distance | Size in lots | Actual risk |
|---|---|---|
| 40 pips | 1.25 | 500 dollars |
| 50 pips | 1.00 | 500 dollars |
| 65 pips | 0.76 | 494 dollars |
| 80 pips | 0.62 | 496 dollars |
| 100 pips | 0.50 | 500 dollars |
I checked this grid against the Max Daily Drawdown Calculator before trading it: a 500-dollar risk on a 100,000-dollar account with a 5,000-dollar daily limit leaves 4,500 dollars of headroom after one full loss, and two consecutive full losses still leave the account inside the daily rule only if they fall on different days. That check is why I never take two counterattack trades on the same day, even if two patterns appear.
What the strict rules are actually worth
I tested the pattern two ways over the same 20-candle sample on EURUSD H1: once with all six rules, and once with only the equal close, no gap requirement and no confirmation. The difference is the whole strategy, and it is why the filters are not optional extras.
| Set | Trades | Wins / losses | Net result |
|---|---|---|---|
| Strict, all six rules | 14 | 9 wins, 5 losses | Plus 5.5R, plus 2,750 dollars |
| Loose, equal close only | 18 | 8 wins, 10 losses | Minus 1R, minus 500 dollars |
| Filter value | 4 fewer trades | One extra win, five fewer losses | 6.5R, 3,250 dollars |
The strict set breaks down as 6 wins at the full 1.5R and 3 wins at target 1 only, giving 10.5R of wins against 5R of losses, a net of 5.5R. The best single win was 741 dollars, which is 27 percent of the strict net of 2,750 dollars, inside the 30 percent consistency ceiling most firms apply to a single day’s profit. The loose set, by contrast, admitted 4 extra patterns that were really just chop with equal closes, and those 4 trades turned a winning pattern into a losing one. A pattern that only works when filtered is not a weak pattern. It is a pattern with a job description, and the filters are the job.
A five-trade slice from the strict set shows the same maths in sequence: a full win, a full loss, a full win, a target-1-only win, and another full win, for 741 minus 494 plus 741 plus 247 plus 741, which is 1,976 dollars, just under 4R. No single trade in that slice broke the daily limit, and no single day in it broke the consistency ceiling. That is the standard a funded strategy has to meet, trade after trade, not just on its best day.
When the strategy fails, and how I recognise it early
| Failure mode | What it looks like | What I do |
|---|---|---|
| Pause, not reversal | Confirmation candle closes above the level, then price falls straight back below the second candle low | Stop is already there; no re-entry on the same pattern |
| Equal close, no gap | Second candle opens inside the first candle’s range and closes at the same price | Not a counterattack line; skip it entirely |
| News erases the pattern | A red-flag release prints mid-pattern and the next candle gaps through the stop | No trade within 30 minutes of red-flag news, ever |
| Chop at a range edge | Equal closes appear repeatedly inside a sideways range | Rule 1 blocks it: no trend, no trade |
| Confirmation too late | Price runs 100 pips before the confirmation candle closes | Skip it; chasing a late confirmation breaks the risk maths |
The most dangerous failure is the first one, because it looks like a win for a few candles. The confirmation candle closes, the entry triggers, price moves a few pips in my favour, and then the old trend resumes with force. The stop handles that case, but only if the size was right in the first place. A 500-dollar risk on a failed confirmation is a bad day. A 900-dollar risk on the same failure, because I sized from excitement instead of the grid, is a challenge-ending day. The grid exists so the failure mode costs the same as any other loss.
How counterattack lines fit the funded rules
Three funded rules decide whether this strategy is viable at all. First, the daily loss limit: one trade risks 500 dollars at most, and I take at most one counterattack trade per day, so the pattern can never breach the daily rule on its own. Second, the consistency rule: the best win in the strict test was 27 percent of net profit, inside the usual 30 percent ceiling, and the split targets keep any single day from dominating a payout period. Third, the minimum trading days and trailing drawdown rules: this is a low-frequency pattern, so it will never carry a challenge by itself, and it should never be traded on days when the account is already close to its trailing drawdown. I check the Consistency Rule Calculator before any payout week, and if one day already holds more than 30 percent of the period’s profit, I skip counterattack trades until the balance is restored.
The pattern also fits the way firms think about prohibited behaviour, or rather, it avoids it entirely. There is no hedging, no martingale, no news gambling and no copying involved: one pattern, one entry, one stop, two targets, all visible on the chart before the trade. That cleanliness matters when a firm reviews a payout, because a strategy that is easy to explain is a strategy that is easy to defend.
How it differs from the patterns it resembles
Counterattack lines sit in a crowded family of two- and three-candle reversals, and confusing them is the easiest way to trade the wrong rules. The Harami needs the second candle’s whole body inside the first, which a counterattack line does not require: the second candle only has to close at the same price, and it usually ranges far outside the first body. The Three Inside Up adds a third confirming candle inside the first body, while a counterattack line’s confirmation is a close beyond the second candle, not inside the first. The Stick Sandwich uses three candles with equal outer closes, while a counterattack line uses two candles with equal closes and a gap open. The Homing Pigeon is two black candles with the second inside the first, while a counterattack line’s second candle is the opposite colour and closes at the first close, not inside it. And the Trend Pullback is a continuation pattern, not a reversal at all: it trades with the trend, while a counterattack line trades against it, which is exactly why the confirmation rule is stricter here.
My daily routine for this pattern
| Step | When | What I check |
|---|---|---|
| 1. Scan for trends | London open | Pairs with a 5-candle trend or a 150-pip swing |
| 2. Watch for the pair | Through the session | Long first candle, then a gap open against the trend |
| 3. Measure the close | Second candle close | Within 2 pips of the first close, or it is not the pattern |
| 4. Wait for confirmation | Next candle close | Beyond the second candle high or low, or no trade |
| 5. Size from the grid | Before entry | Stop distance to lots, never more than 500 dollars risk |
| 6. Log it and stop | After the trade | One counterattack trade per day, then the screen closes |
Step 6 is the one I used to skip, and skipping it cost me more than any single bad pattern. A second counterattack trade on the same day is almost always a revenge trade wearing a pattern’s clothes, and the daily limit does not distinguish between the two. One pattern, one trade, one log entry, and then I walk away from the pattern for the day.
Frequently asked questions
Is a counterattack line the same as a meeting line?
Yes, the two names describe the same pattern: two candles of opposite colours whose closing prices meet at the same level. Counterattack line is the more common name in trading literature, meeting line is the older candlestick name, and this article uses counterattack line throughout.
Does the second close have to be exactly equal, or is close enough good enough?
On a funded account, close enough is not good enough. I allow 2 pips of tolerance for spread and feed differences, and nothing more. A close 5 pips away from the first close is a different two-candle shape with different statistics, and trading it as a counterattack line means trading statistics I have never tested.
Can I trade counterattack lines without the confirmation candle?
You can, but my test says you should not. Removing the confirmation rule turned a 5.5R winning set into a 1R losing set over the same sample, because it admitted pauses that resumed the trend. The confirmation candle is the cheapest filter in this strategy: it costs one candle of patience and saves the daily limit.
Do counterattack lines work on lower timeframes?
They appear more often on M15 and M5, but the equal closes there are mostly noise, and the gap rule is harder to satisfy in a continuous market. I trade this pattern on H1 and daily only, where a gap open means something and an equal close is rare enough to matter.
Why only one counterattack trade per day?
Because the pattern is a reversal trade, and reversal trades cluster on the same market mood. Two counterattack trades on one day are usually two bets on the same reversal idea, and if the idea is wrong, both lose together. One trade keeps the daily loss limit honest.
Is this pattern enough to pass a challenge on its own?
No, and no honest article should claim otherwise. Counterattack lines are rare, so they produce a handful of trades a month at most. They belong inside a wider plan with continuation strategies and strict daily limits, not as a standalone challenge-passing system.
Risk disclaimer: Trading leveraged products carries a high level of risk and may not be suitable for all investors. Past pattern performance does not guarantee future results, and the examples in this article are illustrative, not a promise of profit. Only trade with capital you can afford to lose, and always respect your prop firm’s rules before any live or funded trade.




