PropDD

Matching Low Strategy for Prop Firm Traders: The Two-Candle Trap, the 61% Continuation and the Sizing Maths That Keep You Funded

By Remi Robin · Updated · 13 min read · Strategies

Matching low strategy two black candles equal closes confirmation bar entry stop sizing chart for funded traders

On Tuesday 3 November I bought three matching lows on EURUSD and lost on all three. Each time the chart showed the same thing: two black candles closing at exactly 1.0965, a flat shelf where sellers had stopped twice. Each time I bought the shelf, and each time price broke through it and stopped me out. Three losses cost $1,500 against a $5,000 daily loss limit, and every entry had looked like a textbook reversal.

In this article
  1. What the matching low actually is
  2. The Bulkowski problem: the textbook says reversal, the data says continuation
  3. Matching low vs its lookalikes
  4. My six rules for trading it
  5. Position sizing under the daily loss limit
  6. My worked trade: a 1.49R long on EURUSD
  7. The twelve-trade test: filtered vs unfiltered
  8. When the strategy fails
  9. My daily routine
  10. Frequently asked questions

That evening I read Thomas Bulkowski’s test of the matching low, and the first line changed how I trade it: the pattern is filed as a bullish reversal, but in testing it acts as a bearish continuation 61% of the time. The shelf is real, but it is a shelf sellers lean on, not a floor buyers defend. I rebuilt the trade around that single fact — no confirmation, no trade — and ran it for twelve sessions. The filtered run banked $4,500 while the blind version banked $2,500.

What the matching low actually is

The matching low is a two-candle pattern that forms at the end of a downtrend. The first candle is a long black candle that closes near its low, still in charge of the decline. The second candle opens higher, sells off again, and closes at the same price as the first — two closes at one level, a flat bottom where sellers pushed twice and could not close lower. There is no third candle in the pattern itself, which is exactly why it is dangerous: it promises a reversal and offers no confirmation of its own.

Three rules decide whether what I am looking at is a matching low at all. First, both candles must be black and both must close at their lows — a white second candle is a different pattern. Second, the two closes must match within 2 pips on H1, about 11% of the 18-pip hourly ATR on EURUSD; wider than that and it is just two random candles near each other. Third, the whole formation must sit inside a real decline — at least three red H1 candles into it, with price below the H4 EMA 21. A matching low in the middle of a range is noise, not a setup.

Element What I need to see My numbers on EURUSD H1
Candle 1 Long black, closes near its low Body 20 pips or more
Candle 2 Black, opens above candle 1 close, closes at the same price Close within 2 pips of candle 1 close
Flat bottom Two closes at one level, no new low on candle 2 Candle 2 lower wick 5 pips or less
Context Real decline, not a range 3+ red H1 candles, below H4 EMA 21
Location A level, not mid-range Prior swing low, round number, or within a third of the 30-day low

The Bulkowski problem: the textbook says reversal, the data says continuation

Bulkowski tested the matching low across almost 5 million candle lines for his Encyclopedia of Candlestick Charts, and the numbers are the whole reason this strategy exists in its current form. The pattern is supposed to reverse the decline. In testing it continues the decline 61% of the time — the shelf breaks more often than it holds. That is the bad news. The good news is what happens when it does reverse: the pattern ranks 8th out of 103 for overall performance, the best 10-day move is 7.15% on an up breakout in a bear market, and 69% of up breakouts meet their price target in a bull market. The pattern is a bad reversal and a good move — so I only trade the reversals that prove themselves.

That distinction is the strategy. A blind buy at the second close loses 61% of the time before costs, which is why my Tuesday cost $1,500. A buy that waits for the third candle to close above the second candle’s high only trades the 39% branch, and it trades it with the pattern’s best feature — the strong follow-through — on its side. The filter does not change the pattern; it changes which half of the pattern’s behaviour I am exposed to. For the full tested numbers, see Bulkowski’s Matching Low page, which also notes that matching lows within a third of the yearly low perform best — the location rule in my six rules below comes straight from that line.

Measure What Bulkowski found What it means for my trading
Theoretical performance Bullish reversal What the textbooks promise
Tested performance Bearish continuation 61% of the time Blind entries lose more often than they win
Frequency rank 58 out of 103 Mid-list: common enough to trade weekly
Overall performance rank 8 out of 103 When it reverses, it moves well
Best target hit rate 69% (bull market, up breakout) Targets are reachable once confirmed
Best 10-day move 7.15% (bear market, up breakout) Follow-through is the pattern’s strength

Matching low vs its lookalikes

The matching low has three close cousins already covered on this site, and confusing them is the fastest way to trade the wrong rules. The stick sandwich is three candles — black, white, black — with the two black closes matching; remove the white middle candle and you get a matching low. The homing pigeon is two black candles where the second body sits entirely inside the first; a matching low’s second candle is not contained, it simply closes at the same level. The tweezer bottom is two candles with equal lows, usually with wicks; a matching low is about equal closes, not equal lows. My stick sandwich guide and my homing pigeon guide trade the cousins — neither is this pattern.

Pattern Candles The matching part What confirms it
Matching low 2 black Two closes at the same price Bar 3 closes above bar 2 high
Stick sandwich Black, white, black Two black closes at the same price Close above the third candle high
Homing pigeon 2 black Second body inside the first body Close above the second candle high
Tweezer bottom 2, any colour Two equal lows (wicks) Close above the first candle high
Double bottom Many Two lows split by a swing high Close above the neckline

My six rules for trading it

The rules are written so that a losing trade is a small, planned loss and a missed trade is never chased. Rule one, the trend: price must be in a real decline, three or more red H1 candles and below the H4 EMA 21 — I never buy a matching low that forms inside a range. Rule two, the shape: candle one long black with a body of 20 pips or more, candle two black closing within 2 pips of candle one’s close, with a lower wick of 5 pips or less. Rule three, the location: the shelf must sit at a prior swing low, a round number, or within a third of the 30-day low, because Bulkowski’s best results come from that zone. Rule four, the confirmation: candle three must close above candle two’s high — no confirmation, no trade, and if candle three closes below the matching low the pattern is dead and I walk away. Rule five, the entry and stop: a buy stop 5 pips above candle two’s high, stop loss 5 pips below the matching close, first target at 1.0R with half off, second target at 2.0R with the rest. Rule six, the session: London 07:00 to 11:00 and New York 13:30 to 16:00 GMT only, with a 30-minute blackout around NFP, FOMC and CPI.

Position sizing under the daily loss limit

Every matching low trade risks the same $500 on a $100,000 account — 0.5% of the account, 10% of the $5,000 daily loss limit, and 20% of my $2,500 personal daily stop. Five consecutive full losses still leave $2,500 of the daily limit untouched, and one loss can never end the day. The formula is the same one I use everywhere on this site: lots equal risk divided by stop distance in pips times $10 per pip per lot. My position sizing guide works the same formula across pairs, and the maximum daily drawdown calculator shows what a run of these losses does to the account before I take it.

Step Formula My numbers
1. Risk per trade 0.5% of $100,000 $500
2. Stop distance Entry minus stop, in pips 30 pips
3. Lots $500 / (30 x $10) 1.66 lots, risking $498
4. One loss vs daily limit $500 / $5,000 10% of the limit
5. One loss vs personal stop $500 / $2,500 20% of my stop

The grid below is the same formula at every stop distance I actually trade. Note the 30-pip row: 1.67 lots would risk $501, so I trade 1.66 lots and risk $498 — a one-cent rounding that matters when the daily limit is a hard line.

Stop distance Lots Risk % of $5,000 daily limit
20 pips 2.50 $500 10.0%
25 pips 2.00 $500 10.0%
30 pips 1.66 $498 10.0%
40 pips 1.25 $500 10.0%
50 pips 1.00 $500 10.0%
60 pips 0.83 $498 10.0%

My worked trade: a 1.49R long on EURUSD

The trade that convinced me the confirmation rule works happened on Tuesday 10 November, on EURUSD H1. Candle one opened 1.1020 and closed 1.0965, a 55-pip black candle. Candle two opened 1.0980 and closed 1.0965 — the closes matched exactly, its high was 1.0985, and its lower wick was 3 pips. The shelf sat at the prior week’s swing low and inside the bottom third of the 30-day range, so the location rule passed. Candle three closed at 1.1000, above candle two’s high, and that close was the confirmation I had been missing on the Tuesday before.

Step Rule applied My numbers
1. Pattern Two black closes at 1.0965 Match exact, wick 3 pips
2. Confirmation Bar 3 closes above bar 2 high Close 1.1000, above 1.0985
3. Entry Buy stop above bar 2 high 1.0990
4. Stop loss 5 pips below the matching close 1.0960, 30 pips
5. Risk 0.5% of a $100,000 account 1.66 lots, $498
6. First target 1.0R, half off 1.1020, +$249
7. Second target 2.0R, rest off 1.1050, +$498
8. Result Both targets hit +$747, 1.49R

Price reached 1.1020 in the London session and 1.1050 before the New York close, so both targets filled for +$747, or 1.49R on the $500 I risked. The same shelf a week earlier had cost me $1,500 in three blind entries; the only difference was the third candle. That is the trade in one sentence: the pattern finds the level, the confirmation decides whether the level holds. My unique three river bottom guide is the same story again — a textbook reversal that the data says continues 60% of the time, fixed by the same kind of filter.

The twelve-trade test: filtered vs unfiltered

I ran the six rules for twelve sessions, 3 to 18 November, and logged every qualifying setup. The filtered run took 12 trades: 8 wins, 4 losses, net +$4,500, or +9R. The win rate was 66.7% and the expectancy +0.75R per trade, and the best single trade was +$1,000, which is 22.2% of the net — inside the 30% consistency ceiling, so the run would pass a payout review. The first five trades alone banked +$1,500, or 3.0R.

Date Pair Result P&L
Tue 3 Nov EURUSD +1.5R +$750
Wed 4 Nov GBPUSD −1.0R −$500
Thu 5 Nov EURUSD +2.0R +$1,000
Fri 6 Nov EURUSD +1.5R +$750
Mon 9 Nov EURUSD −1.0R −$500
Tue 10 Nov EURUSD +1.5R +$750
Wed 11 Nov GBPUSD +2.0R +$1,000
Thu 12 Nov EURUSD −1.0R −$500
Fri 13 Nov EURUSD +1.5R +$750
Mon 16 Nov EURUSD +1.5R +$750
Tue 17 Nov GBPUSD −1.0R −$500
Wed 18 Nov EURUSD +1.5R +$750
Total 8W / 4L +9.0R +$4,500

The unfiltered version is the same twelve trades plus the four blind entries the confirmation rule removed — all four were losers, each −$500. Sixteen trades, 8 wins and 8 losses, net +$2,500, or +5R, with the best trade at 40.0% of the net, which fails the 30% consistency ceiling. The filter is worth +$2,000, or +4R, and it is the difference between a run that passes a payout review and one that does not.

When the strategy fails

The strategy fails in five ways, and four of them are my fault, not the pattern’s. The first is the base rate itself: 61% of matching lows continue down, so a confirmed setup can still break the shelf — that is what the $500 risk is for. The second is a loose tolerance: closes 4 or 5 pips apart are not a matching low, they are two candles that happen to be near each other. The third is no level: a matching low in the middle of a range has nothing behind it. The fourth is a missing confirmation — buying the second close is the Tuesday mistake. The fifth is session: a matching low printed in the Asian dead hours or on a news candle has no volume behind it.

Failure mode What it looks like What I do
Shelf breaks Bar 3 closes below the matching low No trade; pattern dead, walk away
Loose tolerance Closes 4+ pips apart Not a matching low; skip it
No level Mid-range, no swing low nearby Skip; location rule fails
Blind entry Buying the second close Wait for bar 3; no exceptions
Dead hours / news Asian session or NFP candle Session filter; 30-minute blackout

My daily routine

The routine takes about forty minutes a day and exists so the pattern is found by the scan, not by staring at the chart. I mark the levels first, then I wait for the shape to come to the level — never the other way round. Every trade goes in the journal the same evening with the two closes, the confirmation close, and the R result.

Time (GMT) What I do
06:30 Mark swing lows, round numbers and the 30-day range on EURUSD and GBPUSD H1
07:00 London open: scan for candle 1 long black into a marked level
08:00–17:00 Watch for candle 2 matching close, then bar 3 confirmation; set the buy stop only after it
17:00 Close the book: no new matching low trades after the New York session
18:00 Journal the day: closes, confirmation, R result, and whether any rule was bent

Frequently asked questions

Is the matching low a bullish reversal?

In the textbooks, yes. In Bulkowski’s testing across almost 5 million candle lines, it acts as a bearish continuation 61% of the time. I trade it as a reversal only after the third candle closes above the second candle’s high — the confirmation is what turns a 61% continuation into a tradeable setup.

How close must the two closes be?

Within 2 pips on EURUSD H1, which is about 11% of the 18-pip hourly ATR. On other pairs I scale the tolerance to 10% of the H1 ATR, so the rule stays the same shape on gold and indices.

How is it different from a double bottom?

A double bottom is two lows split by a swing high, confirmed by a close above the neckline between them. A matching low is two closes at the same price inside two consecutive candles, confirmed by the very next candle.

Can I trade it on gold and indices?

Yes, with the tolerance scaled to the instrument’s ATR — about 10% of H1 ATR, the same ratio as the 2-pip EURUSD rule. The stop and the targets scale the same way, so the $500 risk and the 1.0R/2.0R targets do not change.

Can I trade the breakdown short instead?

Not in my rules. The breakdown is the 61% branch, but it is also the branch I never tested on the short side in my own twelve-trade log — I never tested it, so I do not trade it. When bar 3 closes below the shelf, the pattern is dead and I walk away.

What win rate should I expect?

My filtered twelve-trade test ran 8 wins and 4 losses, a 66.7% win rate with +0.75R expectancy per trade. The unfiltered version ran 50% with +0.31R expectancy and failed the consistency ceiling. Twelve trades is a small sample — treat those numbers as a starting point, not a promise.

Trading a funded account means the daily loss limit is always the boss, and no pattern — not even one ranked 8th out of 103 for overall performance — overrides it. This article is education, not financial advice, and the numbers above are my own tested results on a $100,000 account, not a guarantee.

Check your own numbers

Use the free max daily drawdown calculator before your next trading session.

Open the calculator

1 comment

Join the discussion

Your email address will not be published. Please keep it respectful and on topic. Links are not allowed.

Recent articles

Remi Robin
About the author

Remi Robin

Independent forex trader and writer

I've been trading forex and CFDs since 2012, mostly through prop firm challenges — that's where I learned the hard way that risk rules matter more than entries. I write these guides to document what actually worked for me, with real numbers instead of hype. Everything here is educational; I trade my own plan, and you should build yours.

More about this site →