I finished September up 1,900 dollars on my 100,000-dollar funded account and felt like a genius. Then, on the first Sunday of October, I did something I had never done properly before: I sat down and reviewed the whole month, trade by trade, instead of just admiring the balance. The review took 45 minutes. It found one number that changed everything. My best day in September was plus 1,100 dollars. That is 57.9 percent of the month’s entire profit, and my firm’s consistency rule caps a single best day at 30 percent of total profit. I had made money all month and still would have failed a payout. Nobody had told me. No alert had fired. The account looked healthy, the equity curve pointed up, and the payout would have been refused anyway.
In this article
- What a monthly review actually is
- The eight numbers I pull first
- The consistency maths that decides your payout
- My October, week by week
- Win rate, expectancy and the R-multiple ledger
- The drawdown map: worst day, worst week, peak to trough
- The cost audit: what the market charged me to trade
- Rule breaks and near-misses I almost ignored
- The three fixes I carry into November
- Monthly review vs weekly review
- My 45-minute monthly routine
- Frequently asked questions
That is what a funded account monthly review is for. It is not a victory lap and it is not a diary. It is a 30-day audit: you close the books, pull the same eight numbers every month, check the consistency maths that decides your payout, map your drawdown, audit what the market charged you, log every rule you broke, and leave with three written fixes for next month. My weekly review catches a bad week before it becomes a breach. The monthly review catches the slow drift a weekly scorecard cannot see: a best day creeping toward the ceiling, a cost line quietly eating a quarter of your profit, a rule you have now broken three months in a row. This article is the exact routine I run, with my real October numbers on a 100,000-dollar account: 38 trades, 21 wins, 17 losses, plus 3,900 dollars, and a best day of 28.2 percent that passed the ceiling by less than two points.
What a monthly review actually is
A monthly review is the session where you step back far enough to see trends, but not so far that you are judging the whole strategy. A week is 8 to 10 trades, which is noise. A quarter is 100-plus trades, which is a verdict on the strategy itself. A month is 30 to 40 trades: big enough to measure, small enough to fix. The rule I follow, and the one the JournalX monthly review guide states plainly, is that the monthly review is the only session where you are allowed to change the written plan or your size, because a month is the first sample big enough to justify it. Weekly reviews police the plan. Monthly reviews edit it.
The review has one non-negotiable input: a complete journal. Every fill on the broker statement must be in the journal, including the trades on a second account and the ones you would rather forget. If the journal total and the statement total do not agree to the dollar, stop and reconcile before you calculate anything. My October journal and my statement both said plus 3,900 dollars. September’s agreed too, which is how I know the 57.9 percent best-day figure is real and not a logging error. I run the review on the first Sunday of the new month, before the London open, with the statement open on one side and the journal on the other. Forty-five minutes, same order, same numbers, every month.
The eight numbers I pull first
Every month I fill in the same scorecard and never change what is on it. Comparison only works when months are measured the same way, so the scorecard is fixed. These are the eight numbers, with my October values beside them.
| Number | October | September | What it tells you |
|---|---|---|---|
| Net profit | +$3,900 | +$1,900 | Did the month pay at all |
| Trades taken | 38 | 31 | Sample size for every other number |
| Win rate | 55.3% | 51.6% | How often the plan worked |
| Expectancy per trade | +$102.63 (0.205R) | +$61.29 (0.123R) | What one average trade is worth |
| Best day as share of net | 28.2% | 57.9% | Consistency ceiling: pass or fail |
| Worst day | -$1,300 | -$900 | How close you came to the daily limit |
| Peak-to-trough drawdown | -$1,200 (1.2%) | -$2,100 (2.1%) | How deep the month’s hole was |
| Total trading costs | $922 (23.6% of net) | $741 (39.0% of net) | What the market charged you |
Two of those numbers matter more than the rest on a funded account. The first is the best day as a share of net profit, because that is the number that decides whether a payout is approved. The second is total trading costs as a share of net, because a funded trader who ignores costs is measuring a fantasy. Everything else on the scorecard exists to explain those two. October improved on September in seven of the eight rows, and the one that matters most, the best-day share, fell from a failing 57.9 percent to a passing 28.2 percent. That is the whole story of the month, and I would never have seen it without the review.
The consistency maths that decides your payout
Most funded firms run a version of the same rule: no single day may contribute more than 30 percent of your total profit over the payout period. The rule exists because a firm is not buying one lucky day, it is buying a repeatable trader. My firm’s version is 30 percent, and I check it with the same formula every month.
| Consistency formula | September | October |
|---|---|---|
| Best day profit / month net profit | $1,100 / $1,900 = 57.9% | $1,100 / $3,900 = 28.2% |
| Ceiling (30% of net) | $570 | $1,170 |
| Verdict | FAIL by $530 | PASS by $70 |
| What it would have cost | A refused payout | Nothing, this month |
Read that table carefully, because it contains the uncomfortable truth about October. My best day was exactly the same in both months: plus 1,100 dollars. September failed because the month was small; October passed because the month was bigger. The best day did not improve. The denominator did. That means October’s pass was real but thin, by 70 dollars, and one more quiet week would have pushed it back over the line. The fix is not to trade smaller on good days. The fix is to bank half of any day that runs past plus 800 dollars, so the best day stops growing while the month keeps compounding. I wrote that rule into my plan on 2 November, and it is fix number one in the list at the end of this article. If you take one thing from this piece, take this: check your best-day share every month, because the firm checks it at payout time, and by then it is too late to fix. The full rule, with the worked examples and the daily-pace maths, is in my consistency rule guide.
My October, week by week
A month total hides the shape of the month. September looked like a steady climb until I split it by week and found the entire profit came from a single Tuesday. October’s weekly split tells a healthier story, and it also shows where the risk actually sat.
| Week | Trades | Wins | Losses | Net | Best day | Worst day |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Week 1 (5-9 Oct) | 9 | 5 | 4 | +$900 | +$600 | -$300 |
| Week 2 (12-16 Oct) | 10 | 6 | 4 | +$1,400 | +$700 | -$1,300 |
| Week 3 (19-23 Oct) | 9 | 5 | 4 | +$800 | +$500 | -$400 |
| Week 4 (26-30 Oct) | 10 | 5 | 5 | +$800 | +$1,100 | -$500 |
| Month total | 38 | 21 | 17 | +$3,900 | +$1,100 | -$1,300 |
Three things stand out. First, every week was profitable, which is the first month in the last four where that happened. Second, week 2 was the best week and also held the worst day, minus 1,300 dollars on Wednesday 14 October. A good week and a bad day live in the same row more often than traders admit. Third, week 4 was flat on win rate, five wins and five losses, yet still banked plus 800 dollars, because the wins were bigger than the losses. That is the R-multiple story, and it is the next section. The weekly split also answers the question the month total cannot: was October a good month, or one good day? Four green weeks, with the best day at 28.2 percent of the total, says it was a good month with one strong day inside it. September’s split said the opposite, and that is why September’s review hurt.
Win rate, expectancy and the R-multiple ledger
Win rate is the number traders quote and the number that matters least. October’s win rate was 55.3 percent, 21 wins from 38 trades. September’s was 51.6 percent. The gap looks small, and it is small. What changed the month was not how often I won, it was how much the wins were worth against the losses. That is the R-multiple ledger, and it is the only performance table I trust.
| R-multiple ledger | October | September |
|---|---|---|
| Gross wins | $9,600 | $6,300 |
| Gross losses | -$5,700 | -$4,400 |
| Net profit | +$3,900 | +$1,900 |
| Average win | $457.14 (0.91R) | $393.75 (0.79R) |
| Average loss | -$335.29 (0.67R) | -$275.00 (0.55R) |
| Profit factor (wins / losses) | 1.68 | 1.43 |
| Expectancy per trade | +$102.63 (0.205R) | +$61.29 (0.123R) |
| Net in R-multiples | +7.8R | +3.8R |
The expectancy formula is simple: (win rate x average win in R) minus (loss rate x average loss in R). For October that is (0.553 x 0.91) minus (0.447 x 0.67), which is 0.505 minus 0.300, giving 0.205R per trade. Multiply by 38 trades and you get 7.8R, which at 500 dollars of risk per trade is 3,900 dollars. The ledger ties out exactly, and a ledger that ties out is the difference between a review and a guess.
Expectancy also answers the only forward-looking question a monthly review can answer honestly: how long until the target? My profit target is 8 percent, 8,000 dollars on a 100,000-dollar account. At October’s expectancy of 102.63 dollars per trade, the target needs about 78 trades. At 1.9 trades a day, that is about 41 trading days, roughly two months. The daily pace the target implies is 400 dollars a day, or 0.8R, if I wanted it in one month, but I do not want it in one month. Forcing 0.8R a day from a strategy that makes 0.205R a trade means either doubling size or doubling frequency, and both of those break the daily limit eventually. On my funded account there is no clock on the target, so the honest plan is two months at October’s pace, not one month at twice the risk. A monthly review that ends with “trade bigger” has failed. Mine ends with “trade the same, for longer.”
The drawdown map: worst day, worst week, peak to trough
Profit tells you what you made. Drawdown tells you what it cost you to make it, and on a funded account the cost is measured against hard limits. My daily loss limit is 5 percent, 5,000 dollars. My maximum drawdown is 10 percent, 10,000 dollars. The drawdown map checks how close the month came to either one.
| Drawdown map | October | Share of the limit |
|---|---|---|
| Worst day (Wed 14 Oct) | -$1,300 | 26.0% of the $5,000 daily limit |
| Worst week (Week 2, net) | +$1,400 (best week) | No losing week this month |
| Worst 3-day stretch (13-15 Oct) | -$1,100 | 22.0% of the daily limit |
| Peak equity (28 Oct) | $104,600 | +4.6% on the month |
| Trough after the peak | $103,400 | -$1,200 peak to trough (1.2%) |
| Month-end equity | $103,900 | +$3,900 (+3.9%) |
The worst day deserves a closer look, because it is the only day in October that touched a rule. Wednesday 14 October cost 1,300 dollars: a 2 percent risk trade that lost 1,000 dollars, plus a normal 500-dollar-risk trade that lost 300 dollars on a partial exit. That is 26 percent of my daily limit in one session, and it happened because I doubled my size on a setup I liked too much. The trade is logged in the rule-breaks section below, because it belongs there, not in the drawdown table. The rest of the map is clean. No losing week. The deepest peak-to-trough slide was 1,200 dollars, 1.2 percent of the account, and the month ended 700 dollars below the peak, which is a normal give-back, not a slide. Compare September: a 2,100-dollar peak-to-trough hole, 2.1 percent, on a month that made half as much. October made more and bled less. That is what improvement looks like when you measure it instead of feeling it.
The cost audit: what the market charged me to trade
This is the table most funded traders never build, and it is the one that changed my trading the most. Every trade pays the market a toll: spread, commission, swap for holding overnight, and slippage when the fill is worse than the order. None of it appears in the win rate. All of it comes out of the net.
| Cost line | October | Share of net profit | Per trade (38 trades) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Spread + commission | $684 | 17.5% | $18.00 |
| Swap (overnight holds) | $96 | 2.5% | $2.53 |
| Slippage (fills worse than order) | $142 | 3.6% | $3.74 |
| Total costs | $922 | 23.6% | $24.26 |
Costs took 23.6 percent of October’s net profit. In September they took 39.0 percent, 741 dollars out of 1,900. The improvement came from two places. First, I traded 38 times instead of 31, so the fixed cost per trade fell against a bigger profit. Second, I stopped holding trades overnight for no reason, which cut the swap line from 188 dollars to 96. The spread line is the one I cannot shrink much: 18 dollars a trade on EURUSD and GBPUSD at my size is the market’s price, and the only honest way to beat it is to take fewer, better trades, not to hunt a cheaper broker mid-month. The slippage line is the one I watch closest. It was 142 dollars in October, and 96 of it came from a single NFP trade on 7 October, when my market order filled 9 pips worse than the price on screen. That trade is also in the rule-breaks log. Slippage is not bad luck. It is the receipt for trading into news, and the monthly review is where you add up the receipts.
Rule breaks and near-misses I almost ignored
A monthly review without a rule-break log is a highlights reel. I broke my own rules three times in October, and I log all three, because a rule broken once is a mistake and a rule broken three months in a row is a habit I have chosen.
| Date | Rule broken | What happened | Cost |
|---|---|---|---|
| 7 Oct | 30-minute news blackout | Market order into NFP, filled 9 pips worse | -$300 trade, $96 of it slippage |
| 14 Oct | 0.5% risk per trade | Doubled size to 2% on a setup I liked | -$1,000, part of the -$1,300 worst day |
| 16 Oct | Flat before the weekend | Held GBPUSD over the weekend | -$120 gap loss on Monday’s open |
| Total | 3 breaks | All three were choices, not accidents | -$1,420 |
The three breaks cost 1,420 dollars between them, which is 36.4 percent of the month’s net profit. Read that again. More than a third of October’s profit went to three decisions I had already written rules against. The 14 October size break is the expensive one, and it is also the most honest one to log, because I knew the rule while I was breaking it. I liked the setup, I told myself the extra size was justified, and the market charged me 1,000 dollars for the story. The news trade and the weekend hold were smaller, but they share the same shape: a rule exists because the situation is dangerous, and I traded into the danger anyway. My personal daily stop is set at 2,500 dollars, half the firm’s 5,000-dollar limit, and it is the one rule I did not break in October. The worst day stopped at 1,300 dollars because I walked away after the second loss instead of chasing it. That is the rule that saved the month, and it goes in the review as a keep, not a fix.
The three fixes I carry into November
A monthly review earns its time only if it ends with written changes. Three fixes, no more. More than three and none of them get done. Each fix names the problem it solves, the exact rule, and how I will know it worked.
| Fix | Problem it solves | The written rule | How I will know it worked |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1. Bank half after +$800 days | Best day at 28.2%, passed by only $70 | Past +$800 in a day, close half of every open winner and stop trading new setups | November best day under 25% of net |
| 2. News blackout, no exceptions | NFP trade cost $300, $96 of it slippage | No new trades 30 minutes either side of red-folder news, including “quick” ones | Zero news trades in November, slippage under $50 |
| 3. Risk stays at 0.5%, always | 2% size break cost $1,000 on 14 Oct | Risk per trade is $500 on a $100k account; no “make-up” size after a loss | No single trade risks more than $500 in November |
Notice what is not on the list. There is no fix for the strategy, because the strategy made 0.205R a trade in October, up from 0.123R in September. There is no fix for the win rate, because 55.3 percent with a 1.68 profit factor is a working system. The fixes are all discipline, because discipline was the leak. That is the normal outcome of a monthly review on a funded account: the edge is usually fine, and the trader is usually the problem. The sizing maths behind fix number three is the same grid I use every day, and it is worth printing: at 500 dollars of risk on EURUSD, a 15-pip stop is 3.33 lots, a 20-pip stop is 2.50, a 25-pip stop is 2.00, a 30-pip stop is 1.66, a 40-pip stop is 1.25 and a 50-pip stop is 1.00 lot. Every row risks between 498 and 500 dollars. There is no row for 1,000 dollars, because that row does not exist in my plan any more. The full sizing method is in my position sizing guide, and the maximum daily drawdown calculator is where I check any new size against the 5,000-dollar limit before I take it.
Monthly review vs weekly review
Traders ask whether the monthly review replaces the weekly one. It does not. They answer different questions, on different samples, and they make different decisions. I run both, and the table below is how I keep them apart.
| Question | Weekly review | Monthly review |
|---|---|---|
| When | Every Sunday, 20 minutes | First Sunday of the month, 45 minutes |
| Sample | 8 to 10 trades | 30 to 40 trades |
| Main question | Did I follow the rules this week? | What is changing month to month? |
| Numbers | Win rate, worst day, rule breaks | Expectancy, consistency, costs, drawdown map |
| Decisions it can make | None, except stop trading for the day | Plan edits, risk per trade, next month’s goals |
| What it catches | A bad week before it becomes a breach | Slow drift: costs, best-day creep, repeated breaks |
The weekly review is a guardrail. The monthly review is a steering wheel. Skip the weekly one and a bad Tuesday can breach the account before Sunday. Skip the monthly one and you can trade well for six months, pass every week, and still fail a payout because your best day quietly grew past the ceiling while nobody was measuring it. That is exactly what happened to me in September, and the monthly review is the only session that would have caught it.
My 45-minute monthly routine
The routine is deliberately boring. Same order, same numbers, same 45 minutes, on the first Sunday of every month. Boring is the point: a review you only run when you feel like it is a review you run after the damage is done.
| Step | What I do | Minutes |
|---|---|---|
| 1. Close the books | Match journal total to broker statement to the dollar | 5 |
| 2. Pull the eight numbers | Fill the fixed scorecard: net, trades, win rate, expectancy, best day, worst day, drawdown, costs | 5 |
| 3. Check consistency | Best day divided by net profit, against the 30% ceiling | 5 |
| 4. Read the month week by week | Split the total into four weekly rows and look for the shape | 10 |
| 5. Audit costs and drawdown | Spread, swap, slippage; worst day and peak to trough | 5 |
| 6. Log the rule breaks | Every break with date, rule, cost; plus the one rule that saved the month | 5 |
| 7. Write three fixes and November’s goals | Three fixes max, each with a written rule and a pass mark; process goals, not profit targets | 10 |
| Total | Seven steps, same order, every month | 45 |
November’s goals are process goals, not profit targets, because I control the process and the market controls the profit. The goals are: run all four weekly reviews, log every trade on the day it closes, keep the best day under 25 percent of the month’s net, and take zero news trades. If I hit all four and the month still loses money, the review will say so, and the strategy gets the audit instead of the discipline. That is the deal a monthly review makes with you: it tells the truth either way. My trading journal is where all of this lives, and the margin call rules are what the review protects you from ever meeting. Run the review on the first Sunday of the month, before the open, and let the numbers argue with your memory. Your memory will say the month was fine. The numbers will tell you whether it was.
Frequently asked questions
How long should a funded account monthly review take?
Forty-five minutes, once your journal is complete. The review itself is seven steps: close the books, pull eight fixed numbers, check the consistency maths, read the month week by week, audit costs and drawdown, log rule breaks, and write three fixes. If it takes two hours, the problem is the journal, not the review: log every trade on the day it closes and the monthly session stays short.
What is the most important number in a monthly review?
Your best day as a share of the month’s net profit. Most firms cap a single best day at 30 percent of total profit, and a payout can be refused on that number alone. In my September review the best day was 57.9 percent of the month, which would have failed a payout even though the month was profitable. Check it every month, because the firm checks it at payout time.
How many trades do I need before a monthly review means anything?
Thirty to forty trades is the useful range. Fewer than 20 and the win rate and expectancy are noise. More than 80 and you are probably overtrading a funded account. My October review ran on 38 trades, which was enough to measure expectancy at 0.205R per trade and to trust the consistency check. A week of 8 to 10 trades is too small to judge anything except whether you followed the rules.
Should I change my strategy based on one monthly review?
No. One month is big enough to edit the plan and your size, but too small for a verdict on the strategy. Change discipline first: risk per trade, news rules, the best-day cap. Only change the strategy after two or three months point the same way, with the same numbers, on a decent sample. My October review changed three discipline rules and zero strategy rules, because the strategy made 0.205R a trade and the trader broke rules worth 1,420 dollars.
What is a good win rate and expectancy on a funded account?
There is no single good number, because win rate without the size of wins and losses means nothing. My October was a 55.3 percent win rate with an average win of 0.91R and an average loss of 0.67R, giving an expectancy of 0.205R per trade and a profit factor of 1.68. A 40 percent win rate with 2R wins beats a 60 percent win rate with 0.5R wins. Measure expectancy in R-multiples, not win rate alone.
Do I need paid software to run a monthly review?
No. A spreadsheet with the eight numbers on the scorecard, the broker statement and a journal is enough. Paid journaling tools calculate the same metrics faster, but the review is the thinking, not the arithmetic. The JournalX monthly review guide makes the same point: the value comes from measuring the same numbers the same way every month, and from writing the fixes down. Start with a sheet, and buy software only when the sheet is slowing you down.
Risk disclaimer: This article describes my own funded-account review routine and my own October 2026 results. It is educational content, not financial advice. Trading leveraged products on a funded account can lose the challenge fee and the account, and past monthly results do not predict next month’s. Always read your firm’s rules, including its consistency and daily-loss limits, before you trade.





1 comment
[…] in a year is exactly the kind of slow bleed that takes out a tight stop and then drifts back. My monthly review caught the same pattern in October: my worst losses were not bad entries, they were good entries […]