Last March I lost $1,180 in a single week on a $50,000 evaluation doing everything the textbooks said was right. RSI was oversold, so I bought the dip. RSI was oversold again the next day, so I bought it again. By Friday I had a beautiful collection of long positions and a dashboard that looked like a crime scene. The problem was not my entries being “wrong” — it was that every indicator on my chart was answering the question “is price stretched?” while nobody was answering the question I actually needed: who is stronger right now, the bulls or the bears?
In this article
- What the Elder Ray actually measures
- The two formulas and a five-candle hand-worked example
- My settings for funded accounts
- The four signals I actually trade
- My worked trade: a bearish-divergence short under the daily loss cap
- I tested it: 10 Elder Ray divergences on a 100k demo
- The five mistakes that break this indicator
- How Elder Ray fits prop firm rules
- Frequently asked questions
That is the only question the Elder Ray indicator asks. Developed by Alexander Elder — the psychiatrist-turned-trader who wrote Trading for a Living — it splits the market into two forces measured against one reference line: the 13-period exponential moving average, which Elder called the consensus of value. Bull Power is how far the bulls pushed price above that consensus. Bear Power is how far the bears dragged it below. When I rebuilt my funded-account playbook around it, the first thing that changed was not my win rate — it was that I finally stopped buying dips into downtrends, because the indicator showed me the bears were still in charge while RSI was screaming “oversold”. This is the full guide: the formulas, my H1 settings, the four signals I trade, a worked short with real sizing maths, and a 10-trade test log.
What the Elder Ray actually measures
Forget overbought and oversold for a moment. The Elder Ray is built on one idea: the 13-period EMA represents what the crowd collectively agrees the asset is worth right now — the consensus of value. Every candle’s high tells you how far the bulls managed to push above that consensus before running out of buyers. Every candle’s low tells you how far the bears dragged it below before running out of sellers. Bull Power and Bear Power are those two distances, plotted as histograms above and below a zero line.
This is why it survived my funded-account filter when flashier oscillators did not: bulls and bears are measured in the same units as your stop loss. Bull Power of +18 pips on EURUSD means the bulls pushed price 18 pips above the consensus. That number means something concrete when you are sizing a trade under a 5% daily loss limit — unlike an RSI of 63, which tells you nothing about how far price can travel before your stop is hit. And because it is pure price maths — no volume feed required — it works on spot forex, where the volume indicators on this site (like OBV) are working with tick volume proxies instead of real exchange data.
The indicator needs its reference line to mean something, so the 13-EMA is not decorative — it is the whole point. I wrote a full breakdown of how I use the EMA on funded accounts; the short version is that the 13-period setting reacts fast enough for intraday work without whipping like a 5 or 8.
The two formulas and a five-candle hand-worked example
The entire indicator is two subtractions. The full derivation with Elder’s original rules is on Capital.com’s Elder Ray reference — here they are in one box:
| Elder Ray formulas |
| Bull Power = candle High − 13-period EMA Bear Power = candle Low − 13-period EMA Reading the signs: Bull Power positive = bulls pushed above consensus; Bear Power negative = bears pushed below consensus. A Bear Power reading of +8 is not a typo — it means even the candle’s low stayed above the EMA, so the bears could not reach value at all. My funded-account rule: only consider longs when price is above the 13-EMA and only consider shorts when price is below it. The EMA side is the trend filter; the histograms are the timing tool. |
Let me hand-work five H1 candles so you can see the divergence the indicator is famous for. The EMA values are read straight off the chart — the subtraction is the whole calculation:
| Candle | High | Low | 13-EMA | Bull Power | Bear Power |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 1.0942 | 1.0918 | 1.0926 | +16 pips | −8 pips |
| 2 | 1.0953 | 1.0930 | 1.0934 | +19 pips | −4 pips |
| 3 | 1.0960 | 1.0938 | 1.0942 | +18 pips | −4 pips |
| 4 | 1.0950 | 1.0920 | 1.0946 | +4 pips | −26 pips |
| 5 | 1.0935 | 1.0905 | 1.0940 | −5 pips | −35 pips |
Look at candles 1 through 3: price makes higher highs (1.0942 → 1.0953 → 1.0960) but Bull Power makes a lower high (+16 → +19 → +18). The bulls are pushing price to new highs with less and less force — that is bearish divergence, and it is the single highest-value signal this indicator produces. Candles 4 and 5 confirm it: Bull Power collapses to +4 then negative, Bear Power explodes to −26 and −35. The breakdown was telegraphed two candles early.
My settings for funded accounts
Elder’s defaults are 13 for the EMA on daily charts. For prop-firm intraday trading I keep the 13 but change the context around it. Here is the exact setup I run on my funded accounts:
| Setting | My value | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Timeframe | H1 minimum (M15 only inside London/New York) | On M5 the histograms whip and every tick becomes a “signal” — that is how you manufacture overtrading |
| EMA length | 13 (tested 8 and 21) | 8 reacts to every wick; 21 lags the divergence by 2–3 candles; 13 is the balance point |
| Trend filter | 50-period EMA on the same chart | Longs only above the 50-EMA, shorts only below — divergence against the higher-timeframe trend is a skip |
| Session filter | London (07:00–11:00 GMT) and New York (12:00–16:00 GMT) | Bull/Bear Power needs real participation; Asian-session histograms are thin and lie |
| Instruments | EURUSD, GBPUSD, XAUUSD | Clean EMA behaviour and tight spreads; exotic pairs gap through the reference line |
One prop-firm-specific note on the timeframe: H1 signals mean holds measured in hours, which keeps you far away from minimum holding time rules — the 120-second tripwire that deletes fast profits on funded accounts. An indicator that forces you to wait for the histogram to turn is, accidentally, excellent compliance.
The four signals I actually trade
Elder described several uses; I trade four. Memorise this table and you have 90% of the indicator:
| Signal | What prints | What I do |
|---|---|---|
| Bull-power tick-up | Price above the 13-EMA; Bull Power histogram ticks up after flattening or dipping | Long bias — bulls are re-asserting above value; enter on the tick, not before |
| Bear-power tick-down | Price below the 13-EMA; Bear Power histogram ticks down (more negative) after flattening | Short bias — bears are re-asserting below value |
| Bearish divergence | Price makes a higher high; Bull Power makes a lower high | Prepare a short — the highest-conviction setup; tighten the plan, halve the size |
| Bullish divergence | Price makes a lower low; Bear Power makes a higher low (less negative) | Prepare a long — same rules mirrored |
Two of Elder’s original cautions are worth quoting because beginners invert them constantly. First: do not buy just because Bull Power is positive — buy when it ticks up. A falling Bull Power above zero means the bulls are weakening; that is distribution, not strength. Second: do not short just because Bear Power is negative — short when it ticks down. A rising Bear Power (less negative) below zero means the bears are exhausted. The histogram tick is the trigger, not the divergence. Divergence tells you where to look; the tick tells you when to act. Entering on the divergence alone is how you catch the two extra candles of pain in my five-candle table above.
My worked trade: a bearish-divergence short under the daily loss cap
Let me put real numbers on the candle-3 setup from the hand-worked table, because this is where prop-firm trading differs from textbook trading — the entry is only half the trade; the sizing under the daily loss limit is the other half.
The setup: EURUSD H1, price printing 1.0960 (higher high), Bull Power +18 against the previous +19 (lower high), price below the 50-EMA trend filter — wait, no. Check the filter first: in this example the 50-EMA sat at 1.0972, so price was below it. Trend filter says shorts only. Divergence says prepare a short. Both agree.
Entry: short at 1.0950, the break of candle 3’s low area once candle 4 confirmed the breakdown. Stop: 1.0962 — above candle 3’s high plus a 2-pip buffer. That is a 12-pip stop. Target: 2R, which is 24 pips down at 1.0926.
Now the sizing, done the way I size everything on a funded account — 0.5% risk on a $100,000 account is $500, and I verify the plan against the Max Daily Drawdown Calculator before I touch the platform:
| Step | Maths | Result |
|---|---|---|
| Account risk | 0.5% × $100,000 | $500 |
| Stop distance | 1.0962 − 1.0950 | 12 pips |
| Pip value needed | $500 ÷ 12 pips | $41.67 per pip |
| Position size | $41.67 ÷ $10 per pip per lot | 4.17 lots |
| Target (2R) | 1.0950 − 24 pips | 1.0926 → +$1,000 |
| Share of daily limit | $500 ÷ $5,000 daily loss limit | 10% — one loss never threatens the day |
If you are new to this sizing chain, my position sizing guide walks through the same steps slowly. The habit that matters: the trade is planned backwards from the daily loss limit, not forwards from the entry. And because the stop sits above a real swing high rather than at an arbitrary distance, the 12-pip invalidation is honest — if price takes out 1.0962, the divergence thesis is simply wrong. My personal daily stop sits at $3,000, below the firm’s $5,000, so even six full losses in a row would not end my day.
I tested it: 10 Elder Ray divergences on a 100k demo
Talk is cheap, so I forward-tested the divergence signals — tick entry only, 50-EMA filter on, session filter on — for ten qualifying setups on a $100,000 demo at $500 risk per trade. Every trade was sized through the drawdown calculator first. Here is the log:
| Trade | Setup | Entry → stop | Result |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Bullish divergence, GBPUSD | 1.2685 → 1.2660 | +2.1R win |
| 2 | Bearish divergence, EURUSD | 1.0950 → 1.0962 | +1.6R win |
| 3 | Bullish divergence, XAUUSD | 2,341.0 → 2,336.5 | −1.0R loss |
| 4 | Bearish divergence, GBPUSD | 1.2740 → 1.2762 | +2.4R win |
| 5 | Bullish divergence, EURUSD | 1.0820 → 1.0808 | −1.0R loss |
| 6 | Bearish divergence, XAUUSD | 2,388.5 → 2,394.0 | +1.8R win |
| 7 | Bullish divergence, US30 | 39,120 → 39,020 | +1.5R win |
| 8 | Bearish divergence, EURUSD | 1.0990 → 1.1001 | −1.0R loss |
| 9 | Bullish divergence, GBPUSD | 1.2590 → 1.2568 | +1.9R win |
| 10 | Bearish divergence, GBPUSD | 1.2815 → 1.2830 | −1.0R loss |
The totals: 6 wins, 4 losses (60%), average winner +1.88R, net +7.3R — about +$3,650 at $500 risk per trade. Two observations. First, the losers are all exactly −1R because the invalidation is mechanical — the histogram thesis breaks, the stop takes you out, no drama. Second, the winners average nearly 2R because divergence entries sit close to the turn; the stop is small relative to the move that follows. I ran the same 60% / +1.88R / −1R profile through the Risk of Ruin Calculator and the ruin probability rounds to effectively zero — which is exactly the profile a funded account wants: small, frequent, capped losses funding occasional multiples.
The five mistakes that break this indicator
Every one of these cost me money before I wrote it down:
1. Trading divergence against the 50-EMA trend. A bullish divergence below a falling 50-EMA is a counter-trend bounce, not a reversal. My rule: divergence against the higher-timeframe trend is a skip, full stop.
2. Running it on M5. The histograms need completed candles to mean anything. On M5 you get sixteen “ticks” a day, most of them noise, and you will overtrade yourself into the daily loss limit by lunch. H1 minimum.
3. Misreading Bear Power direction. Bear Power “rising” means less negative — the bears weakening. I shorted into rising Bear Power twice before the penny dropped. Read the sign, not the word.
4. Entering on the divergence instead of the tick. Divergence can persist for three, four, five candles while price grinds higher. The divergence is the setup; the histogram tick is the entry. Anticipating the tick is just guessing with extra steps.
5. Sizing divergence trades like trend trades. Divergence is early by design — you are fading the last push of a move. I size divergence entries at half my normal risk (0.25% instead of 0.5%) and only scale to full size once the tick confirms and price breaks the EMA. The test log above used 0.5% throughout for clean maths; in live funded trading I would have risked half on most of those entries.
How Elder Ray fits prop firm rules
An indicator earns its place on a funded account by respecting the rulebook, not just by making pretty signals. Here is how Elder Ray scores:
| Prop firm rule | Elder Ray fit |
|---|---|
| Daily loss limit (e.g. 5%) | Divergence entries have tight, honest invalidations (12 pips in my worked trade) — small stops mean small percentage risk per trade, so one loss never threatens the day |
| Consistency rule | The histogram tick is mechanical: no discretion, no “it felt right”. Mechanical entries produce the even results consistency rules reward |
| Minimum holding time | H1 signals resolve over hours, not seconds — structurally compliant with 2-minute and 3-minute minimum-hold rules |
| News blackout | Divergence fails on red-folder spikes (histograms reprint violently) — skip 30 minutes either side of high-impact news, no exceptions |
| Overtrading / trade caps | Properly filtered, this setup fires 1–3 times a day across three instruments — it is an anti-overtrading indicator by construction |
Frequently asked questions
What settings work best for Elder Ray on a funded account?
The 13-period EMA with H1 charts, a 50-EMA trend filter, and a London/New York session filter. That combination gave me the cleanest divergence signals in testing. Shorter EMA lengths (8) react to every wick; longer ones (21) delay the divergence by several candles. Keep the 13 and change the context, not the core.
Is Elder Ray better than RSI for prop firm trading?
They do different jobs. RSI measures momentum stretch — how far price has moved. Elder Ray measures pressure — whether bulls or bears are actually winning the current battle around fair value. I use them as a pair: RSI divergence plus Elder Ray divergence on the same turn is a much stronger signal than either alone. If you must pick one for a funded account, pick the one that sizes your stop — Elder Ray’s absolute units do that, RSI’s 0–100 scale does not.
Does Elder Ray work on gold and indices?
Yes — and this is one of its quiet advantages. Because Bull and Bear Power are measured in price units rather than normalised percentages, the indicator adapts to any instrument automatically. Just widen your stops to match the instrument’s volatility: my XAUUSD divergence trades used 45–55 pip-equivalent stops versus 12 pips on EURUSD, sized to the same $500 risk.
Why did my divergence fail?
The three usual causes: you traded it against the 50-EMA trend, you entered before the histogram ticked, or a news spike repriced everything mid-setup. Divergences are early by design — they fade the last push of a move — which is why I halve position size on them until the tick confirms. A failed divergence with a 12-pip stop is a cheap lesson; a failed divergence with a 40-pip stop is an expensive one.
Can I automate Elder Ray signals in an EA?
The histogram tick is easy to code — it is just a comparison of two consecutive bars. But check your firm’s EA and automation rules first; some firms restrict EAs to specific behaviours, and unattended trading has its own compliance footprint. My HFT rules guide covers what counts as problematic automation.
Do I need volume data for Elder Ray?
No. It is pure price maths — highs, lows and an EMA. That is precisely why it works on spot forex, where true volume does not exist and volume-based indicators are working with proxies. If your broker’s volume feed is thin, Elder Ray does not care.
Risk disclaimer: I trade a demo-tested, rule-based plan on funded accounts and I still lose trades — four of the ten in my test log. Nothing here is financial advice. Size every position from your daily loss limit first, and never risk money you cannot afford to lose.





1 comment
[…] is worth separating this system from its cousin on this site, Elder Ray. Elder Ray measures Bull Power and Bear Power against the same 13-period EMA — how far the high […]