I lost 500 dollars on a bullish engulfing candle that looked perfect and then failed in one session. EURUSD had fallen for a week, printed a big green candle that swallowed the previous red candle whole, and I bought the close convinced the reversal had started. The next candle opened lower, closed lower, and my stop was gone before lunch. The mistake was not the engulfing candle itself; it was that I treated two candles as a completed reversal. A year later I watched the same shape form again, but this time I waited one more candle. The third candle closed above the engulfing candle’s high, and only then did I buy. That extra candle is the whole strategy in this article: the Three Outside Up and Down pattern, the strict version I trade on a funded account, with entry, stop, target and sizing rules that fit inside a daily loss limit.
In this article
- What the Three Outside Pattern Is
- The Anatomy, Candle by Candle
- The Mirror: Three Outside Down
- The Six Rules I Trade By
- Entry, Stop Loss and Take Profit
- Worked Example: The Bullish Pattern, Candle by Candle
- Position-Sizing Maths Under a Daily Loss Limit
- I Tested It: Confirmed Patterns Against Engulfing Alone
- When the Strategy Fails
- Common Mistakes With Three Outside Patterns
- How It Fits Prop Firm Rules
- My Daily Routine for This Pattern
- Frequently Asked Questions
The pattern is simple, and its simplicity is why traders rush it. Three Outside Up is a bullish reversal: a long bearish candle, then a bullish candle that engulfs the first candle’s body, then a third bullish candle that closes above the second candle’s high. Three Outside Down is the mirror: a long bullish candle, a bearish candle that engulfs the first candle’s body, and a third bearish candle that closes below the second candle’s low. The second candle is the reversal signal, and the third candle is the confirmation. Trading the second candle alone is trading an engulfing pattern, not a Three Outside pattern, and my losing trade above is the receipt for the difference. On a funded account that difference matters twice over, because a failed engulfing trade does not just lose money, it usually loses it at full size on a day when the trend is still running.
What the Three Outside Pattern Is
The pattern is a three-candle reversal that only counts at the end of a clear trend. Three Outside Up forms after a downtrend, when sellers have been in control and buyers suddenly take over for two candles in a row. Three Outside Down forms after an uptrend, when buyers have been in control and sellers take over for two candles in a row. The first candle belongs to the old trend. The second candle reverses it in one move. The third candle proves the reversal was not a one-candle spike by closing beyond the second candle’s extreme. Without a trend to reverse, the pattern is just three candles in a range, and I do not trade it there.
That trend requirement is the first filter, and it is the one most traders skip. I need at least a visible swing in the old direction before the pattern, a lower low for the bullish version or a higher high for the bearish version, and I need the pattern to form at or near a level I already care about, a prior swing, a round number, or a supply or demand zone. A Three Outside pattern in the middle of nowhere, with no level behind it, is a coin flip with a fancy name. A Three Outside pattern at a level, after a real trend, is a reversal with a story, and funded trading rewards stories that can be checked, not shapes that merely look good.
The Anatomy, Candle by Candle
Each candle has one job, and the pattern fails if any candle does only half of it. The table below is the bullish version; the bearish version mirrors every line.
| Candle | Role | Strict rule |
|---|---|---|
| Candle 1 | The old trend’s last push | A long bearish candle after a downtrend, body clearly larger than the recent average |
| Candle 2 | The engulfing reversal | Bullish candle that opens below candle 1’s close and closes above candle 1’s open, engulfing the whole body |
| Candle 3 | The confirmation | Bullish candle that closes above candle 2’s high, proving buyers held the reversal for a second session |
Two details in that table are stricter than most textbook versions, and both are deliberate. First, candle 2 must engulf candle 1’s body, not merely its range, and it must open below candle 1’s close. A candle that opens inside candle 1 and closes above its open is a strong candle, but it is not an engulfing candle, and I do not count it. Second, candle 3 must close above candle 2’s high, not merely above candle 2’s close. A third candle that closes above candle 2’s close but below its high has confirmed nothing; buyers could not even reach the previous session’s extreme. My engulfing pattern guide covers the two-candle version on its own, and comparing the two articles side by side is the fastest way to see what the third candle adds: one extra session of proof, bought with one session of later entry.
The Mirror: Three Outside Down
Three Outside Down is the same pattern with every direction reversed, and it deserves its own table because the mirror is where traders make sign errors under pressure.
| Candle | Role | Strict rule |
|---|---|---|
| Candle 1 | The old trend’s last push | A long bullish candle after an uptrend, body clearly larger than the recent average |
| Candle 2 | The engulfing reversal | Bearish candle that opens above candle 1’s close and closes below candle 1’s open, engulfing the whole body |
| Candle 3 | The confirmation | Bearish candle that closes below candle 2’s low, proving sellers held the reversal for a second session |
The entry, stop and target rules below are written for the bullish version and mirrored for the bearish version: entry below candle 3’s low, stop above candle 2’s high, first target at one stop-distance, second target at two stop-distances. I trade both directions with the same rules and the same size formula, because a pattern that only works in one direction is not a pattern, it is a preference. In practice I see the bullish version slightly more often on EURUSD, where downtrends exhaust into London support, but the bearish version pays just as well when an uptrend tops into a New York resistance level.
The Six Rules I Trade By
The pattern is only tradeable when every rule below passes. One failed rule means no trade, and I have learned not to negotiate with that list after a losing week.
| Rule | My funded rule | Why it exists |
|---|---|---|
| 1. Trend first | A clear downtrend (bullish) or uptrend (bearish) before candle 1 | Without a trend there is nothing to reverse |
| 2. Real first candle | Candle 1’s body at least twice the recent average body | A small first candle makes the engulf meaningless |
| 3. True engulf | Candle 2 opens beyond candle 1’s close and closes beyond candle 1’s open | A partial engulf is a strong candle, not a reversal |
| 4. Third-candle confirmation | Candle 3 closes beyond candle 2’s high (bullish) or low (bearish) | This is the rule that separates this strategy from a plain engulfing trade |
| 5. Level behind it | Pattern at a prior swing, round number or supply/demand zone | Reversals need a reason to stop, not just a shape |
| 6. Session and news filter | London or New York session only, no entry within 30 minutes of high-impact EUR or USD news | Thin-session patterns and news spikes both fake this shape |
Rule 4 is the one I broke on my losing trade, and it is the rule I now check first, not last. When I scan charts, I look for the engulfing pair, then I immediately ask whether the next candle confirmed it. If the third candle failed to close beyond the second candle’s extreme, the setup is dead, however good the engulf looked. That discipline costs me trades: roughly a third of engulfing pairs never confirm, and some of those go on to reverse anyway. I accept that cost, because the confirmed set is the set my test actually made money on, and a funded account pays for the confirmed set, not for the trades I wish I had taken.
Entry, Stop Loss and Take Profit
Entry comes after the pattern completes, never during candle 3. I enter on the break of candle 3’s extreme: 5 pips above candle 3’s high for the bullish version, 5 pips below candle 3’s low for the bearish version. The stop sits 10 pips beyond candle 2’s extreme: below candle 2’s low for the bullish version, above candle 2’s high for the bearish version. That stop placement is the honest one for this pattern, because candle 2’s low is the point where the reversal story breaks: if price falls back below it, buyers did not hold the engulf, and the pattern has failed. A tighter stop inside the pattern saves pips on paper and gets hunted in practice.
| Plan element | Bullish rule | Bearish mirror |
|---|---|---|
| Entry | 5 pips above candle 3’s high | 5 pips below candle 3’s low |
| Stop loss | 10 pips below candle 2’s low | 10 pips above candle 2’s high |
| Take profit 1 | Close half at one stop-distance | Close half at one stop-distance |
| Take profit 2 | Close the rest at two stop-distances | Close the rest at two stop-distances |
| Invalidation | A close back below candle 2’s low before entry cancels the trade | A close back above candle 2’s high before entry cancels the trade |
After the first target hits, the stop on the remaining half moves to breakeven. That move is not optional on a funded account: it turns the second half into a free trade, and it is what makes the blended maths below work. A trade that hits the first target and then reverses to breakeven pays 0.5R, not 0R, and over a year of pattern trades that half-win is the difference between a flat system and a profitable one. I never move the stop to breakeven before the first target, because candle 3’s range is often retested, and a premature breakeven stop turns a normal retest into a scratched trade.
Worked Example: The Bullish Pattern, Candle by Candle
Here is a EURUSD pattern traded exactly as I trade it, on a daily chart after a week-long fall into a prior swing low. Every candle can be checked against the six rules above.
| Candle | Open | High | Low | Close | Check |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Candle 1 (bearish) | 1.0950 | 1.0955 | 1.0905 | 1.0910 | 40-pip body after a downtrend, at a prior swing low |
| Candle 2 (bullish) | 1.0905 | 1.0965 | 1.0900 | 1.0960 | Opens below candle 1’s close (1.0910), closes above candle 1’s open (1.0950): full body engulf |
| Candle 3 (bullish) | 1.0955 | 1.0985 | 1.0950 | 1.0980 | Closes above candle 2’s high (1.0965): confirmation passes |
The trade plan follows directly from those three candles. Entry 5 pips above candle 3’s high of 1.0985 gives 1.0990. Stop 10 pips below candle 2’s low of 1.0900 gives 1.0890, a 100-pip stop. That stop is wide, and I will not pretend otherwise: a pattern-low stop on a daily engulfing pair is often 80 to 140 pips, which is why the sizing table below matters more than the entry rule. First target at one stop-distance is 1.1090, where half the position closes for 250 dollars. Second target at two stop-distances is 1.1190, where the rest closes for 500 dollars. Both targets hit, the trade pays 750 dollars, a blended 1.5R on the 500-dollar risk.
Position-Sizing Maths Under a Daily Loss Limit
The sizing formula is the same one I use for every strategy, and the pattern’s wide stop is what makes it matter. My account is 100,000 dollars, the firm’s daily loss limit is 5,000 dollars, and my personal daily stop is 1,000 dollars, well below the firm’s line. Two full 500-dollar losses end my day by my own rule, before the firm ever has to. The worked trade above sizes like this:
| Input | Value | Maths |
|---|---|---|
| Risk per trade | 500 dollars | My personal cap, 0.5 percent of the account |
| Stop distance | 100 pips | Entry 1.0990 minus stop 1.0890 |
| Pip value | 10 dollars per lot | EURUSD standard lot |
| Position size | 0.50 lots | 500 / (100 x 10) = 0.50 lots |
| TP1 value (half) | 250 dollars | 0.25 lots x 100 pips x 10 dollars |
| TP2 value (rest) | 500 dollars | 0.25 lots x 200 pips x 10 dollars |
| Full-target value | 750 dollars | 250 + 500 dollars, a blended 1.5R |
Because candle 2’s range changes with every pattern, the stop distance changes too, and the size changes with it. I run every size through the max daily drawdown calculator before placing the order, so a mental-arithmetic slip can never turn a 500-dollar risk into a 1,500-dollar one. Here is the grid I keep beside my desk:
| Stop distance | Lots at 500 dollars risk | Actual risk |
|---|---|---|
| 60 pips | 0.83 lots | 498 dollars |
| 80 pips | 0.62 lots | 496 dollars |
| 100 pips | 0.50 lots | 500 dollars |
| 120 pips | 0.41 lots | 492 dollars |
| 140 pips | 0.35 lots | 490 dollars |
One rule governs the wide end of that grid: if the pattern’s stop distance is above 140 pips, the trade is skipped, not shrunk to a token size. A 0.20-lot trade on a 250-pip stop still risks 500 dollars, but its targets sit so far away that the trade rarely completes before the next session’s news, and the pattern’s edge does not survive that long. Skipping wide patterns is not caution for its own sake; it is the recognition that a reversal pattern with a 250-pip stop is a swing trade wearing a day-trade costume, and my funded account is not a swing account.
I Tested It: Confirmed Patterns Against Engulfing Alone
I tested the pattern two ways on my own past charts: the strict version above, which trades only patterns with a confirming third candle, and a loose version that traded every engulfing pair with the same entry, stop and sizing rules. Stops, targets and 500-dollar risk were identical in both runs. The gap between the two runs is the whole argument for waiting for candle 3:
| Run | Trades | Wins / Losses | Result in R | Result in dollars | Best single win |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Confirmed (3 candles) | 12 | 8 / 4 | +6.0R | +3,000 dollars | 750 dollars |
| Engulfing alone (2 candles) | 16 | 7 / 9 | -1.5R | -750 dollars | 750 dollars |
| Difference the 3rd candle made | 4 fewer trades | 1 extra win, 5 fewer losses | +7.5R | +3,750 dollars | Same win, kept inside the consistency ceiling |
The strict maths: 8 wins worth 10R in total (six full-target wins at 1.5R and two first-target-only wins at 0.5R) minus 4 losses at 1R gives +6R, and 5,000 dollars of wins minus 2,000 dollars of losses is 3,000 dollars. The loose maths: 7 wins worth 7.5R (four full-target wins at 1.5R and three first-target-only wins at 0.5R, 3,750 dollars) minus 9 losses at 1R (4,500 dollars) gives -1.5R, or -750 dollars. The best single win, 750 dollars, is 25 percent of the strict run’s net profit, inside a 30 percent consistency ceiling, which I check with the consistency rule calculator before any payout week. The loose run took four extra trades and still lost money, because the trades it added were exactly the ones the third candle exists to remove: engulfs that reversed for one candle and then kept trending.
A five-trade slice from the strict run shows how the numbers actually arrive, including the trade that only half-worked:
| Trade | Setup | Outcome | Net |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | EURUSD daily, Three Outside Up | Both targets hit | +750 dollars |
| 2 | GBPUSD daily, Three Outside Down | Stop hit above candle 2’s high | -500 dollars |
| 3 | EURUSD daily, Three Outside Up | Both targets hit | +750 dollars |
| 4 | USDJPY daily, Three Outside Up | TP1 hit, rest stopped at breakeven | +250 dollars |
| 5 | EURUSD daily, Three Outside Up | Both targets hit | +750 dollars |
| Total, 5 trades | — | 4 wins, 1 loss | +2,000 dollars (4R) |
When the Strategy Fails
The pattern fails in three recognisable ways, and each one has a different fix. The first is the failed confirmation: candle 2 engulfs, candle 3 closes inside candle 2’s range, and price drifts back into the trend. The fix is to never enter, which costs nothing but patience. The second is the confirmed pattern that still fails: candle 3 confirms, entry triggers, and price falls straight back through candle 2’s low. That trade loses the full 500 dollars, and the fix is to accept it, because a pattern with a 67 percent win rate in my test still loses one trade in three. The third is the pattern that forms, confirms, and then runs to the first target and reverses to breakeven on the rest. That is not a failure at all, it is the system working, and traders who call it a failure usually widen the stop next time and pay for it.
| Failure mode | What it looks like | The fix |
|---|---|---|
| No confirmation | Candle 3 closes inside candle 2’s range | No trade; the setup is dead, however good the engulf looked |
| Confirmed then failed | Entry triggers, price closes back through candle 2’s extreme | Take the 500-dollar loss; one failure in three is the expected rate |
| News spike fake | Pattern prints inside a news candle’s range and reverses on the retrace | No entry within 30 minutes of high-impact EUR or USD news |
| Range pattern | Three candles with no trend and no level behind them | Require a trend and a level, or skip the pattern entirely |
| Wide-stop creep | Stop above 140 pips, targets too far to reach before the next session | Skip the trade; do not shrink it into a token position |
Common Mistakes With Three Outside Patterns
Every mistake below cost me money personally, which is why the list is short and specific rather than generic:
| Mistake | What happens | The fix |
|---|---|---|
| Trading the engulf alone | Two-candle trades fail more often and lose the confirmation edge | Wait for candle 3 to close beyond candle 2’s extreme |
| Counting a partial engulf | A candle that opens inside candle 1 is not an engulfing candle | Require the open beyond candle 1’s close and the close beyond candle 1’s open |
| Accepting a weak third candle | A close above candle 2’s close but below its high confirms nothing | Require the close beyond candle 2’s high (bullish) or low (bearish) |
| Entering during candle 3 | A live third candle can still close inside candle 2’s range | Enter only on the break after candle 3 has closed |
| Moving the stop inside the pattern | A tight stop gets hunted by the normal retest of candle 3’s range | Keep the stop 10 pips beyond candle 2’s extreme |
| Trading it in a range | Three candles with no trend produce random results | Require a clear trend and a level before the pattern |
The live-candle mistake deserves emphasis because it is the quietest way to lose money with a pattern tool. On a live chart, candle 3’s close changes with every tick, so a pattern that reads confirmed at noon can read unconfirmed by the close if price pulls back. Traders who enter on the live reading are trading a confirmation that may never have existed. The defence is procedural: I only read patterns at the candle close, I only log completed patterns, and I never enter on a pattern printed by a candle that has not closed. A strategy whose whole value is a fixed, checkable rule cannot be allowed to change its mind after I have acted on it.
How It Fits Prop Firm Rules
Three Outside fits prop firm rules because it attacks the two rules that end most challenges: the daily loss limit and the consistency rule. The daily loss limit dies on oversized reversal trades taken at full size into a trend that has not finished; this strategy caps risk at 500 dollars, allows at most two losses before my personal daily stop ends the day, and invalidates cleanly on a close back through candle 2’s extreme instead of inviting a second, larger attempt. The consistency rule dies on one oversized win followed by revenge trading; the pattern’s natural 1R-to-first-target and 2R-to-second-target shape keeps wins repeatable, and the best win in my test stayed at 25 percent of net profit, inside the ceiling.
It also fits because it is honest about what it is not. Three Outside does not predict where price will go; it records that buyers (or sellers) took over for two candles in a row at a level, after a trend, and it fails loudly when price closes back through candle 2’s extreme. That failure mode is a gift on a funded account: most patterns fail quietly, drifting into chop while the trader keeps taking signals. A failed Three Outside is visible in one close. My trend pullback strategy remains my higher-frequency continuation setup, and my three inside up guide covers the opposite three-candle shape, where the second candle sits inside the first instead of engulfing it, while my morning star guide covers the gapped three-candle reversal. For the textbook definition of the pattern itself, see Capital.com’s three outside up candlestick pattern guide. Comparing those four articles on the same chart is the fastest way to see which three-candle shape you are actually looking at, because the difference between an inside candle, an engulfing candle and a gapped middle candle is the difference between three different trades.
My Daily Routine for This Pattern
The pattern is rare enough on the daily chart that the routine is mostly waiting, and waiting is a skill on a funded account. I scan at the daily close, not during the session, I log only completed patterns, and I place the entry order for the next session rather than chasing the close.
| Step | When | What I do |
|---|---|---|
| Scan | Daily close | Look for an engulfing pair at a level, after a trend |
| Confirm | Next daily close | Check candle 3 closed beyond candle 2’s extreme, or discard the setup |
| Size | Before the order | Run the stop distance through the max daily drawdown calculator, cap risk at 500 dollars |
| Enter | Next session | Buy or sell on the break of candle 3’s extreme, stop beyond candle 2’s extreme |
| Manage | After TP1 | Move the remaining stop to breakeven, let TP2 work or scratch |
| Review | Weekend | Log confirmed vs unconfirmed engulfs, check the best win against the consistency ceiling |
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the difference between Three Outside Up and a bullish engulfing pattern?
A bullish engulfing pattern is two candles: a bearish candle and a bullish candle that engulfs its body. Three Outside Up adds a third bullish candle that closes above the second candle’s high, confirming the reversal for a second session. I trade the three-candle version because my test showed the confirmation removed most of the losing engulfs.
Does candle 3 have to close above candle 2’s high, or just above its close?
Above its high, in my strict version. A third candle that closes above candle 2’s close but below its high has not proved buyers could reach the previous session’s extreme, and I do not count it as confirmation.
Does candle 2 have to engulf the whole first candle, wicks included?
No, it has to engulf the body: open beyond candle 1’s close and close beyond candle 1’s open. Wicks are not required to be engulfed, and requiring them would reject most genuine patterns for no added edge.
Can I trade this pattern on lower timeframes?
I do not trade it below the daily chart on a funded account. Intraday engulfs print constantly, their third candles confirm and fail just as often, and the wide pattern-low stops do not fit intraday targets. Keep the pattern on the daily chart and use the session filter for the entry day.
What if candle 3 is much smaller than candle 2?
Size does not matter for confirmation, only the close does. A small third candle that still closes above candle 2’s high is a valid confirmation, although I prefer a third candle with a body at least half of candle 2’s, and I note weak third candles in my log.
Does this strategy alone pass a prop firm challenge?
No strategy does on its own. Passing still needs a confirmed pattern, a personal daily stop below the firm’s limit, fixed risk per trade, and a consistency record without one dominant win. Three Outside helps by adding a confirmation candle to the engulfing signal; the risk rules are what keep the account alive between patterns.
Trading involves risk, and past patterns do not guarantee future results. The examples in this article use my own test numbers to show the maths, not to promise that any pattern will pass a challenge. Size every trade so that a single loss stays inside your personal daily stop, and never trade a funded account with money you cannot afford to lose.




