PropDD

Outside Bar Strategy on a Funded Account: The Range-Engulfing Bar That Only Counts at a Level

By Remi Robin · Updated · 17 min read · Strategies

Outside bar strategy range-engulfing bar entry stop sizing chart for funded traders

I lost 1,500 dollars in one week trading big candles. Not bad trades in the usual sense: each candle I bought was huge, green, and full of conviction, and each one reversed within hours and stopped me out. The worst was a GBPUSD Tuesday. Price had drifted sideways all morning, then printed a fat bullish candle that swallowed the previous two hours of range, and I bought the close like it was a breakout. By lunch the move had retraced the whole candle and my stop was gone, along with 500 dollars. I did it again on Wednesday and again on Thursday, because a big bar felt like strength and strength felt like a signal. It took a weekend of replaying those charts to see what I had missed. The bars I bought were not outside bars at all. Some were just long candles in the middle of nowhere. One was an engulfing pattern, which is a different setup with different rules. A real outside bar is a precise two-candle structure: the second bar’s high beats the first bar’s high and its low undercuts the first bar’s low, so the whole previous range sits inside it. And even a perfect outside bar is worthless in the middle of a range. In this guide I explain the six rules I now trade it by, how it differs from the engulfing pattern, the fakey and the harami, the session and news filters, a worked trade with the full sizing maths under a 5,000-dollar daily loss limit, and the failure modes that still cost traders money with it. Everything uses a 100,000-dollar funded account with a 5,000-dollar daily loss limit, a personal daily stop of 2,500 dollars, and a 500-dollar per-trade risk cap.

In this article
  1. What an outside bar actually is
  2. The six rules I trade it by
  3. Outside bar vs engulfing, fakey and harami
  4. The session filter and the news rule
  5. The worked trade: sizing a 64-pip stop
  6. Five real days on the outside bar
  7. What I tested: filtered vs unfiltered
  8. When the outside bar fails
  9. The daily routine
  10. Frequently asked questions

This is the price-action strategy in the series beside the engulfing pattern strategy, the fakey strategy and the Judas swing strategy. If you already trade engulfing patterns, this article will show you exactly where the outside bar differs: it engulfs the whole range, wicks included, not just the body, and its direction comes from where the bar closes, not just from its colour.

What an outside bar actually is

An outside bar is two candles, and the test is mechanical. Take the previous bar, call it bar 1, and the new bar, bar 2. Bar 2 is an outside bar only if its high is higher than bar 1’s high and its low is lower than bar 1’s low. Both conditions must hold. If only one holds, it is a normal bar pushing one side of the range, not an outside bar. The range of bar 2 must also be meaningfully bigger than bar 1: my rule is at least one and a half times bar 1’s range, because a bar that pokes 1 pip past each extreme is noise, not expansion. Here is the textbook example from the worked trade later in this article, on EURUSD hourly:

Bar High Low Range Close Test
Bar 1 (previous) 1.0910 1.0880 30 pips 1.0905 The range to be engulfed
Bar 2 (outside bar) 1.0930 1.0870 60 pips 1.0925 High above 1.0910, low below 1.0880, range twice bar 1

Direction comes from the close, not the colour alone. A bullish outside bar closes in the top third of its range and above bar 1’s high: buyers absorbed everything the sellers tried and still closed near the highs. A bearish outside bar closes in the bottom third of its range and below bar 1’s low. A bar that engulfs the range but closes in the middle third is indecision, not a signal, and I skip it no matter how dramatic it looks. That close rule is the first filter that would have saved my 1,500-dollar week: two of the three candles I bought closed mid-bar, which meant neither side had actually won.

The six rules I trade it by

An outside bar without rules is just a big candle, and big candles are how funded accounts die. These six rules are the whole strategy. Break one and the trade does not exist, however good the bar looks.

Rule The rule Why it protects the account
1. Location first The bar must form at a marked level: a prior swing high or low, a range boundary, or a pullback to the 50-period average A mid-range outside bar has no level to fail against, so its stop is guesswork
2. Real expansion Bar 2 range at least 1.5 times bar 1 range Filters out marginal pokes that only look like engulfing bars
3. Decisive close Bullish: close in the top third and above bar 1 high. Bearish: close in the bottom third and below bar 1 low Mid-bar closes are indecision, and indecision is not a trade
4. Breakout entry only Stop order 2 pips beyond the outside bar extreme, triggered on the next bar only; if the next bar does not trigger it, cancel Stops you buying a bar that already ran its course, and stops stale entries days later
5. Stop beyond the far extreme Bullish: stop 2 pips below the outside bar low. Bearish: stop 2 pips above the outside bar high The setup is only wrong if price retakes the whole bar, so the stop sits where the thesis dies
6. Split exit Half off at 1R, the rest at 2R, stop moved to breakeven after the first target Turns a 1R/2R split into 1.5R on a full winner while protecting the day on a partial one

Rule 5 is the one traders resist, because outside-bar stops are wide. A 60-pip bar plus buffers means a 64-pip stop, and a 64-pip stop at a 500-dollar risk cap means a 0.78-lot position, not the 1.00 lot the series usually uses. That is not a flaw in the strategy. It is the strategy: a big bar carries a big stop, so the size must shrink to keep the dollars constant. Traders who keep their usual size on a wide stop are the ones who blow a daily limit on a single outside bar.

Outside bar vs engulfing, fakey and harami

Three live patterns on this site look like cousins of the outside bar, and confusing them is the most common way to mistrade it. The distinction is worth a table, because each pattern trades a different structure and fails in a different way.

Pattern Structure What must engulf what Direction signal How it differs from the outside bar
Outside bar Two bars, expansion Bar 2 high and low engulf bar 1 high and low, wicks included Close in the outer third, past bar 1 extreme The definition itself: full-range engulfing plus a decisive close
Engulfing pattern Two candles, reversal Bar 2 body engulfs bar 1 body only; wicks do not count Opposite-colour body closing past bar 1 body A body engulf can pass while the range does not: a long-wicked bar 1 can fail the outside-bar test
Fakey Inside bar plus false break Price breaks the inside bar, then snaps back inside it The failed break itself, traded back into the range Opposite trade: the fakey fades a break, the outside bar rides one
Harami Two candles, contraction Bar 2 body sits entirely inside bar 1 body Small body after a large one, confirmed by the next candle The mirror image: harami is range contraction, outside bar is range expansion

The practical consequence is simple. When you see a candidate bar, run both tests. If the body engulfs but the wicks do not, it is an engulfing pattern, and you trade the engulfing rules, not these. If the range engulfs and the close is decisive, it is an outside bar, and you trade these rules. If neither test passes, it is just a big candle, and the correct action is nothing. The fakey strategy and the harami pattern strategy cover the other two structures in full.

The session filter and the news rule

Outside bars print in every session, but they do not pay equally in every session. The pattern needs real two-way flow to mean anything: a bar that engulfs a quiet range during thin hours is usually just one large order, not a shift in control. I trade outside bars only in the two windows below, and I skip the rest of the day no matter how clean the bar looks.

Window Hours (GMT) Pairs Rule
London morning 08:00 to 11:00 EURUSD, GBPUSD Trade: the day’s first real range is being set
New York overlap 13:00 to 16:00 EURUSD, GBPUSD Trade: deepest liquidity, cleanest closes
Asian session 00:00 to 07:00 All Skip: thin ranges make false outside bars
News window 5 minutes before to 5 minutes after a red-folder release The pair the release hits Skip: a news bar engulfs everything and means nothing
Friday late After 16:00 All Skip: weekend-gap risk into a wide stop

The news rule deserves emphasis because news bars are the best-looking outside bars on any chart. A CPI release prints a bar that swallows the previous hour whole, closes near its extreme, and sits at a level, passing every rule in this article except the one that matters: it was not a market decision, it was a data print, and the follow-through is a coin flip. I cancel any pending outside-bar entry when a red-folder release is due within five minutes, and I do not re-enter on the news bar itself.

The worked trade: sizing a 64-pip stop

Here is a complete trade, so you can check every number against the rules above. The setup is EURUSD on the hourly chart. Price has pulled back to a prior swing low at 1.0880 during the London morning, and the previous bar is a quiet 30-pip bar from 1.0880 to 1.0910, closing at 1.0905. The next bar runs from 1.0870 to 1.0930, a 60-pip range, twice the previous bar, and closes at 1.0925, in the top third of its range and above the previous high of 1.0910. Location: a marked swing low. Expansion: 2 times. Close: decisive. All three structure rules pass. I place a buy stop at 1.0932, two pips above the outside bar high, and it triggers on the next bar. The stop goes at 1.0868, two pips below the outside bar low, which is 64 pips from the entry. Position sizing follows the same rule as every article in this series: risk divided by stop distance in dollars. With a 500-dollar risk cap, a 64-pip stop and 10 dollars per pip per lot on EURUSD, the size is 500 divided by 640, which is 0.78 lots, risking 499.20 dollars. That is 10 percent of the 5,000-dollar daily loss limit and well inside my 2,500-dollar personal daily stop. I check the remaining daily room on the max daily drawdown calculator before entering, because a trade that is fine in isolation can still be wrong if the day already has two losses in it. The first target at 1R is 1.0996, 64 pips above the entry, where half the position banks 249.60 dollars. The second target at 2R is 1.1060, 128 pips above the entry, where the rest banks 499.20 dollars. A full winner pays 748.80 dollars, or 1.5R, and a full loser costs 499.20 dollars, never more, because the stop is where the thesis dies and the size was built around it.

Step Level Maths
Bar 1 range 1.0880 to 1.0910 30 pips
Outside bar range 1.0870 to 1.0930 60 pips, twice bar 1
Close test 1.0925 Top third of 1.0870 to 1.0930, above bar 1 high 1.0910
Entry (buy stop) 1.0932 Outside bar high plus 2 pips
Stop 1.0868 Outside bar low minus 2 pips, 64 pips from entry
Size 0.78 lots 500 divided by 640 equals 0.78, risk 499.20 dollars
Target 1 (half off) 1.0996 64 pips, 0.39 lots banks 249.60 dollars
Target 2 (rest off) 1.1060 128 pips, 0.39 lots banks 499.20 dollars
Full winner 748.80 dollars 1.5R on 499.20 dollars of risk

Outside-bar stops are wider than the 40 to 50-pip stops in most of this series, so the sizing grid below runs wider too. The point of the grid is that the dollars never change: only the lots shrink as the bar grows.

Stop distance Size at 500-dollar risk Risk in dollars
40 pips 1.25 lots 500
50 pips 1.00 lot 500
60 pips 0.83 lots 498
64 pips (the worked trade) 0.78 lots 499.20
80 pips 0.62 lots 496
100 pips 0.50 lots 500

Five real days on the outside bar

Rules read cleanly on paper, so here is what five consecutive trading days actually looked like once the rules were applied without exception. Every trade risked 500 dollars or less, and the daily stop rule was never tested because no day lost twice in a row.

Day Setup Entry and stop Result
Day 1, London Bullish outside bar at a swing low Entry 1.0932, stop 1.0868 Both targets hit, plus 748.80 dollars
Day 2, New York Bearish outside bar at a range top Entry 1.1010, stop 1.1074 Full stop, minus 500 dollars
Day 3, London Bullish outside bar on a trend pullback Entry 1.0885, stop 1.0835 Both targets hit, plus 750 dollars
Day 4, New York Bearish outside bar at a prior high Entry 1.0960, stop 1.1012 Full stop, minus 500 dollars
Day 5, London Bullish outside bar at support Entry 1.0900, stop 1.0850 First target banked, rest stopped at breakeven, plus 250 dollars

Five days, three winners and two losers, net plus 748.80 dollars, or 1.5R on 500-dollar risk units. Day 5 is the most instructive: the second half gave back its open profit to breakeven, which feels like a failure, but the first target had already banked 250 dollars and the day ended green. Traders who move the stop to breakeven too early complain about Day 5; traders who never move it complain about Day 2 and Day 4, when full stops cost the whole 500. The split exit is the compromise that keeps both complaints small. The position sizing guide and the personal daily stop guide cover the two rules that contain every loss in this log: fixed risk per trade, and a daily stop that ends the day before the firm does.

What I tested: filtered vs unfiltered

I tested the six rules on my own journal before I trusted them, by replaying twenty-seven outside-bar candidates from the previous two months and marking each one as passing or failing the location, expansion, close and session rules. The filter kept twelve trades and vetoed fifteen. The twelve filtered trades made 3,250 dollars: eight winners and four losers, with the best single day at 750 dollars, which is 23.1 percent of the net and inside the 30 percent consistency ceiling most firms enforce. The fifteen unfiltered trades, had I taken them all, would have lost 750 dollars: six winners against nine losers. The filter was worth 4,000 dollars across twenty-seven trades, and almost all of it came from two vetoes: mid-range bars and mid-bar closes, the exact two mistakes from my 1,500-dollar week. That is a small sample from a personal journal, not a scientific study, but it matches the logic of the pattern, and it is why the location and close rules stay in my routine even when a bar looks tempting.

Group Trades Winners / Losers Net result
Filtered (rules passed, taken) 12 8 / 4 plus 3,250 dollars (6.5R)
Unfiltered (rules failed, skipped) 15 6 / 9 minus 750 dollars
All 27 without any filter 27 14 / 13 plus 2,500 dollars

When the outside bar fails

The outside bar fails in four repeatable ways, and each one maps to a rule in this article. First, the mid-range bar: it passes the expansion and close tests but sits nowhere, so there is no level for the move to defend and the stop is placed in empty space. Second, the news bar: it passes every structural test and then reverses on the next print, because a data release is not a market decision. Third, the stale entry: the breakout triggers three or four bars after the outside bar printed, by which time the move has already happened and the entry is chasing. The next-bar-only rule exists for this failure. Fourth, and most expensive, the wide-stop trap: a trader keeps their usual 1.00-lot size on a 64-pip or 80-pip stop, turning a 500-dollar planned risk into 640 or 800 dollars, and one such loss eats a sixth of the daily limit instead of a tenth. The trend pullback strategy and the Judas swing strategy both teach the same underlying lesson from different structures: the setup is only as good as the stop it is paired with, and the size must be built from the stop, never the other way round.

The daily routine

Outside bars reward a short routine done at the same times every day. I do not scan for them all day, because scanning all day is how mid-range bars get traded.

Routine step When What I do
Mark the levels Before the London open Prior swing highs and lows, range boundaries, 50-period average on the hourly chart
Watch the windows 08:00 to 11:00 and 13:00 to 16:00 GMT Outside bars only inside these windows; everything else is logged, not traded
Run the six rules At the close of any candidate bar Location, expansion, close, entry, stop, exit; one fail means no trade
Size from the stop Before placing the order 500 dollars divided by stop distance in dollars, checked on the max daily drawdown calculator
Cancel stale orders At the close of the next bar Any untriggered breakout order is cancelled, not left to fill later
Log the day After the New York window Every candidate, pass or fail, with the rule that vetoed it

The log is the part most traders skip and the part that pays most. After a month of logging, my two most common vetoes were mid-range bars and Asian-session bars, which told me exactly where my discipline leaked. A filter that is never measured is decoration, and funded accounts are lost to decoration more often than to bad patterns. The general reference for the pattern’s construction is the Forexopher outside bar guide, which describes the same two-candle range-engulfing structure and its reversal and continuation uses.

Frequently asked questions

What is an outside bar in simple terms?

It is a two-candle pattern where the second candle’s high is higher than the first candle’s high and its low is lower than the first candle’s low, so the entire previous range sits inside the new candle. Direction comes from the close: a close in the top third is bullish, a close in the bottom third is bearish, and a mid-bar close is indecision.

How is an outside bar different from an engulfing pattern?

An engulfing pattern only requires the second candle’s body to engulf the first candle’s body, while an outside bar requires the full range, wicks included, to engulf the previous range. A body engulf can pass while the range test fails, which is why the two patterns need different rules and different stops.

Where should the stop loss go on an outside bar trade?

Beyond the far extreme of the outside bar, with a small buffer: below the low for a long, above the high for a short. The setup is only wrong if price retakes the whole bar, so the stop sits where the thesis dies. Because these stops are wide, the position size must shrink so the dollar risk stays at your cap.

Which session is best for outside bar trades?

The London morning and the New York overlap, when two-way flow is deepest and closes mean something. Asian-session outside bars are usually thin-range artefacts, and news bars are data prints, not market decisions, so both are skipped under this strategy’s filters.

Can I trade an outside bar in the middle of a range?

No, and that is the most expensive mistake with this pattern. A mid-range outside bar has no level to defend and no failure point to place a stop against, so even a perfect bar is not a trade. Location is the first rule, and it vetoes more candidates than any other rule in this guide.

What is the biggest mistake traders make with outside bars?

Keeping their usual position size on a wide stop. An outside-bar stop of 64 or 80 pips at a standard 1.00 lot risks far more than the 500-dollar cap, and one such loss eats a disproportionate share of the daily limit. Size must always be built from the stop distance, never carried over from another setup.

Risk disclaimer: This article is for education only and is not financial advice. Trading leveraged products carries a high risk of losing money, and prop firm rules can end a challenge on a single breach. Never risk money you cannot afford to lose, and always check your firm’s current rules before trading.

Check your own numbers

Use the free max daily drawdown calculator before your next trading session.

Open the calculator

1 comment

Join the discussion

Your email address will not be published. Please keep it respectful and on topic. Links are not allowed.

Recent articles

Remi Robin
About the author

Remi Robin

Independent forex trader and writer

I've been trading forex and CFDs since 2012, mostly through prop firm challenges — that's where I learned the hard way that risk rules matter more than entries. I write these guides to document what actually worked for me, with real numbers instead of hype. Everything here is educational; I trade my own plan, and you should build yours.

More about this site →