PropDD

Balance of Power: The Buyer-Seller Score That Stopped Me Trading Against the Tape

By Remi Robin · Updated · 13 min read · Indicators

Balance of power buyer seller score candle chart for funded traders

I lost a funded trade I should never have taken, on a candle that looked strong and was not. It was a Thursday on a $100,000 funded account, EURUSD had been climbing all morning, and the latest H1 candle closed near its high. Green candle, higher close, everything my eyes wanted to see. I bought the next open. Within two hours I was stopped out, and when I finally looked at the candle properly I understood why: it had opened near its low, spiked up, then spent most of the hour falling back, closing only a little above where it started. The close was green, but the sellers had controlled most of the bar. I had read the colour and missed the fight inside the candle.

In this article
  1. What Balance of Power actually measures
  2. The formula, worked by hand
  3. Settings that fit a funded account
  4. How to read its signals
  5. Sizing the trade under a daily limit
  6. Ten trades I tested it on
  7. When Balance of Power lies
  8. Frequently asked questions

That was the week I started scoring every candle instead of admiring it. The Balance of Power indicator does exactly that: it takes one bar and asks who won it, buyers or sellers, and by how much. The answer is a single number between -1 and +1, and on a funded account that number is worth more than most multi-line indicators because it is built from the candle itself, needs no volume feed, and tells you whether your entry bar actually agrees with your trade.

What Balance of Power actually measures

Balance of Power, usually written BOP, measures control, not movement. A bar can travel a long way and still score near zero if it opens and closes in the middle of its range, because neither side held the close near an extreme. A small bar can score near +1 if it opens at its low and closes at its high, because buyers controlled the whole bar from start to finish. That distinction is the whole point: most traders ask how far price moved, while BOP asks who kept it there.

On a funded account this matters because daily-loss rules punish entries taken against the tape. A long entered on a bar that sellers actually won is a trade that starts underwater for a structural reason, not bad luck. BOP is price-only, which is a genuine advantage on spot forex, where the volume feed is tick volume from one broker rather than true traded volume. Indicators that need volume, such as the Klinger oscillator or Ease of Movement, inherit that weakness; BOP does not, because it uses only open, high, low and close. It is also different from the momentum indicators already covered on this site: RSI scores closes against prior closes, and the Chande Momentum Oscillator scores up-moves against down-moves over a window, while BOP scores a single bar’s internal fight. I link to both below so the contrast is easy to check.

The formula, worked by hand

The formula is one line, and that simplicity is why I trust it enough to calculate it by hand when a signal looks suspicious. Igor Livshin introduced it in the technical press around 2001, and the standard build is described in the LuxAlgo Balance of Power guide.

Step What to do Example bar (EURUSD H1)
1. Close minus open How far the close moved from the open 1.0890 – 1.0850 = +0.0040
2. High minus low The bar’s full range 1.0900 – 1.0840 = 0.0060
3. Divide BOP = (Close – Open) / (High – Low) 0.0040 / 0.0060 = +0.67

A reading of +0.67 says buyers won that bar convincingly: the close sat two-thirds of the way from open toward the high side of the range. The mirror bar tells the opposite story. Take a bar that opens at 1.0890, reaches 1.0905, falls to 1.0860 and closes at 1.0865: (1.0865 – 1.0890) / (1.0905 – 1.0860) = -0.0025 / 0.0045 = -0.56, sellers in control. A bar that opens at 1.0870 and closes at 1.0872 inside a 1.0850 to 1.0890 range scores (0.0002 / 0.0040) = +0.05, which is balance, not strength, however dramatic the wicks looked. If high equals low, the division is undefined and the reading is zero by convention, which is the honest answer for a bar that went nowhere.

The raw reading jumps around bar to bar, so almost nobody trades it raw. The standard practice is to smooth it with a simple moving average, usually 14 periods, and read the smoothed line against zero. Fourteen raw readings summing to +2.10 give a smoothed reading of +0.15: buyers ahead on balance, but not dominant. That smoothed line is the version I trade, and every signal in this article refers to it unless I say raw.

Settings that fit a funded account

BOP has almost nothing to tune, which is a feature on a funded account: fewer knobs means fewer ways to overfit a setting to last week’s chart. I use one build everywhere and change only the timeframe, never the maths.

Setting My value Why
Smoothing 14-period simple moving average The standard build; long enough to kill single-bar noise, short enough to turn within a session
Zero line 0, the control flip Above zero buyers lead, below zero sellers lead; no overbought or oversold band needed
Timeframes H1 for entries, H4 for regime M15 raw BOP whipsaws; H1 smoothed is the fastest reading I trust with real money
Extreme filter Smoothed beyond +0.50 or -0.50 Flags one-sided control; I never chase an extreme, I wait for the turn back toward zero
Confirmation Price structure, never BOP alone A level, a trendline or a prior swing must agree before any entry

Do not shorten the smoothing to 5 or 7 periods to make it feel responsive. On H1 that turns BOP back into a noise machine, and a funded account pays for every false flip with real drawdown. Do not lengthen it to 50 either: by the time a 50-period smoothed line crosses zero, the move it was meant to catch is usually half over and your stop distance has widened with it.

How to read its signals

BOP gives four usable signals, and I rank them in the order I trust them. The zero-line cross is the regime signal: when the smoothed line crosses above zero and stays there, buyers have taken control of the recent bars, and I favour longs; below zero, I favour shorts. I do not enter on the cross itself. I use it as a filter, so I only take long setups while smoothed BOP is above zero and short setups while it is below. That one filter removed most of my against-the-tape trades, including the Thursday loser from the opening.

The second signal is divergence. When price makes a higher high but smoothed BOP makes a lower high, buyers are winning by less each time they push: the trend is tiring even though the chart looks strong. When price makes a lower low but BOP makes a higher low, sellers are losing grip. Divergence never enters a trade on its own; it tells me to stop adding to the trend direction and to start looking for the reversal setup at the next level.

The third signal is the extreme reading. A smoothed reading beyond +0.50 means buyers have dominated a run of bars; beyond -0.50 means sellers have. Extremes do not mean reversal is imminent, they mean the move is one-sided and therefore fragile: I tighten stops on trend trades and I refuse fresh entries in the extreme direction, because the risk of buying the top of a buyer-controlled run is exactly how funded accounts bleed.

The fourth signal is the raw bar-quality filter, and it is the one I use most often. Before entering any setup, I check the raw BOP of the signal bar itself. A long entry bar should score positive, ideally above +0.30; a short entry bar should score negative, ideally below -0.30. If my setup says buy but the entry bar scores -0.40, sellers won the very bar I am about to buy, and I wait for the next bar. This single check is cheap, takes five seconds, and has saved more daily-limit room than any other rule in this article.

Sizing the trade under a daily limit

My account is $100,000 with a $5,000 daily loss limit, and my personal rule is $500 of risk per trade, which is 0.5% of the account and 10% of the daily limit. BOP does not set the stop distance; price structure does. BOP decides whether the trade is allowed at all, and the stop distance decides the size. The formula never changes: lot size equals risk divided by stop distance in pips times pip value. On EURUSD one standard lot is $10 per pip, and I check every size against the max daily drawdown calculator before I trade it.

Stop distance Calculation Lot size
20 pips 500 / (20 x 10) 2.50 lots
30 pips 500 / (30 x 10) 1.67 lots
40 pips 500 / (40 x 10) 1.25 lots
50 pips 500 / (50 x 10) 1.00 lot
60 pips 500 / (60 x 10) 0.83 lots

The stop goes beyond the structure that would prove the BOP reading wrong: below the swing low for a long, above the swing high for a short, never at a round number chosen for comfort. The first target is 1R, where I close half, and the second target is 2R, where I close the rest, following the same partial closes routine I use for every pattern. If the 2R target is not reachable before the next level, the trade fails my room test and I skip it, however clean the BOP reading looks.

Ten trades I tested it on

I ran BOP as a filter for ten H1 EURUSD trades over two weeks, with the same rules every time: smoothed BOP above zero for longs and below zero for shorts, raw entry bar scoring beyond 0.30 in the trade direction, stop beyond structure, half closed at 1R and the rest at 2R. No trade was taken against the smoothed reading, and no entry bar was accepted below the raw threshold. The log below is the full record, not a highlight reel.

Trade Direction Smoothed BOP Raw entry bar Result
1 Long +0.22 +0.58 +1.5R
2 Short -0.18 -0.44 -1.0R
3 Long +0.31 +0.71 +1.5R
4 Short -0.27 -0.62 +1.5R
5 Long +0.15 +0.38 -1.0R
6 Short -0.33 -0.51 +1.5R
7 Long +0.28 +0.66 +1.5R
8 Short -0.21 -0.47 -1.0R
9 Long +0.19 +0.42 +1.5R
10 Short -0.24 -0.55 -1.0R

Six wins at 1.5R give 9.0R, four losses at 1.0R cost 4.0R, so the net is +5.0R, which is +$2,500 at $500 of risk per trade. The average winner is 1.5R and the best single trade is $750, exactly 30% of the net, sitting on the edge of a 30% consistency cap rather than comfortably inside it. That is the honest shape of this test: a filter that kept me on the right side of the tape, not a holy grail. The four losers all shared one trait worth noting: the smoothed reading was close to zero, between -0.27 and +0.31, on every losing trade, which is what a weak-regime filter looks like when it is about to be tested by chop.

When Balance of Power lies

BOP lies in exactly the conditions where every oscillator lies, and a funded trader should know them before trusting a reading. First, inside a range, smoothed BOP crosses zero constantly as bars alternate control, and every cross looks like a regime change that is not one. I ignore zero crosses entirely when price is inside a known range and only use the raw bar-quality filter at the range edges. Second, on tiny bars, a decisive close scores near +1 or -1 even though almost nothing happened: a 5-pip inside bar closing at its high is not buyer dominance, it is a quiet bar. I check the bar’s range against recent average range before believing an extreme raw score. Third, at news spikes, one violent bar can drag the smoothed line across zero and hold it there for hours while price reverses; I do not trade BOP signals within thirty minutes of red-folder news. Fourth, BOP measures control, not importance, so a strong reading at a meaningless level is still a meaningless level: structure decides, BOP only votes.

Failure mode What it looks like My rule
Range chop Repeated zero crosses, no follow-through Ignore crosses inside a range; use the filter only at edges
Tiny decisive bars Raw near +1 or -1 on a 5-pip bar Check range versus average range before believing it
News spikes One bar flips the smoothed line for hours No BOP entries within 30 minutes of red-folder news
Strong reading, weak level Clean BOP at a random midpoint No level, no trade, however clean the score

My daily routine with BOP is deliberately boring. I check the H4 smoothed reading first for regime, then drop to H1 and mark the levels. I only look at setups in the regime direction, I score the entry bar before entering, and I log the smoothed and raw readings next to every trade so the next review can see whether the filter or my discipline failed. That routine pairs naturally with the RSI guide for momentum context and the Chande Momentum Oscillator guide for a zero-centred comparison: RSI asks how strong closes have been, CMO asks whether up-moves beat down-moves, and BOP asks who won the bar in front of you. Three different questions, and on a funded account I would rather have three answers than one loud one.

Frequently asked questions

Is Balance of Power better than RSI for funded traders?

Neither is better in general; they answer different questions. RSI measures close-to-close momentum over a window, while BOP measures control inside each bar. I use BOP as an entry filter and RSI for momentum context, and I would not replace one with the other.

What is a good Balance of Power reading for an entry?

For the smoothed line, I want the reading on the trade’s side of zero. For the raw entry bar, I want beyond +0.30 for a long or below -0.30 for a short. A raw score near zero means neither side won the entry bar, and I wait for the next one.

Why smooth Balance of Power with 14 periods?

Fourteen is the standard build and it balances noise against responsiveness on H1. Shorter smoothing whipsaws, longer smoothing lags, and changing the setting per trade is overfitting. I keep 14 everywhere and change the timeframe instead.

Does Balance of Power need volume data?

No. It uses only open, high, low and close, which is why it works cleanly on spot forex where true volume is unavailable. Volume-based indicators inherit the tick-volume weakness; BOP avoids it entirely.

Can Balance of Power alone pass a funded challenge?

No indicator alone passes a challenge. BOP is a filter that keeps entries on the right side of the tape, but entries still need a level, a stop beyond structure, and sizing that respects the daily loss limit. The challenge is passed by risk rules, not by any single reading.

What is the biggest Balance of Power mistake?

Trading the raw reading bar by bar. Raw BOP flips constantly, and every flip looks like a signal. Smooth it, read it against zero, check the entry bar, and never let a single bar overrule price structure.

Risk disclaimer: This article describes how I use an indicator on a funded account. It is not financial advice, and trading leveraged products can lose more than your initial deposit. Always size positions so that a single loss cannot breach your daily loss limit.

Check your own numbers

Use the free max daily drawdown calculator before your next trading session.

Open the calculator

Join the discussion

Your email address will not be published. Please keep it respectful and on topic. Links are not allowed.

Recent articles

Remi Robin
About the author

Remi Robin

Independent forex trader and writer

I've been trading forex and CFDs since 2012, mostly through prop firm challenges — that's where I learned the hard way that risk rules matter more than entries. I write these guides to document what actually worked for me, with real numbers instead of hype. Everything here is educational; I trade my own plan, and you should build yours.

More about this site →